Live data from Hacker News

What Is Agile?

news.ycombinator.com

11–17 of 17 posts

Re: What Is Agile?

#13
To answer the fundamental question "What is Agile" is simple:

It's a bullshit panacea that pretends to address all concerns around the uncertainty inherent in the production and delivery of complex software.

Every methodology claims to be agile, most of which are not, and claim to provide managers and MBAs the ability to prognosticate accurately - none of which actually do.

If you eliminated entire layers of management and non-technical people from software development, you wouldn't have anyone talking about "Agile" or "Agile Methodologies" at all.

Re: What Is Agile?

#16
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Discussing what you're doing and then doing it and then going home.

Sounds like Agile

It does, doesn't it?...

On the off chance this flew over some heads, my entire point was the the alternative to "Agile" is actually being agile.

It's astonishing how many people in this industry get paid to spend their entire day on step 1. Just talking about work all day. It's all just talk. Disgusting.

Re: What Is Agile?

#17

"Agile is Dead": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-BOSpxYJ9M . Good talk about Agile if you havn't seen :)

This is a talk by Dave Thomas whose name is on the Agile Manifesto.

I highly recommend giving it a watch.

In short, “Agile” with capital A is a cult-like training and process-defining industry gone out of control, causing more harm than good and the opposite of agile.

agile development, as defined in the manifesto is simple and productive - make a step forward, look around, adjust, make another small step.

Post reply on HN