Live data from Hacker News

We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

news.ycombinator.com

11–20 of 451 posts

Re: We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

#11
post #4

How does the Substack App fit into the picture with apps like Matter and Instapaper (and their integrations with programs like Readwise?) Is this for the more casual / sane reader, and is meant to coexist alongside the more power-user apps like Matter?

Our ambition is to make the Substack app a great place to read, and as a writer a great way to have a direct connection with your audience. We have a lot of respect for apps like Matter (and Google Reader back in the day).

For now it's probably most compelling for folks who already do a lot of reading powered by Substack, but we're interested in adding more support for reading non-Substack things (and we already have some basic support for reading Substack stuff in other RSS readers.)

Re: We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

#14
post #7

Any plans for a native macOS app for Substack?

Sachin here (from Substack). I for one would be stoked about a MacOS app, although it's probably not the highest priority thing right now :)

Our next step within the Apple universe will most likely be to build an amazing iPad optimized experience. Right now the app works on iPad, but it's definitely not as great as it could be. A better iPad app would also be a good starting foundation for MacOS (and work on Silicon macs out the gate).

Re: We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

#15

Isn't this post abusing Show HN? Since it's essentially just a marketing post and is void of all technical detail? I understand there's an essence of Show HN posts that are marketing but at least most are technically oriented in some way...

They have a live free app that you can download, play with, and give feedback on. So far so good.

However, it appears you have to create an account to interact with the app at all, which is not in the spirit of Show HN.

If a new startup posted a Show HN that required giving a live email address, they would be criticized for it (and most people probably wouldn’t go any further).

EDIT: it would be great if one of the founders could create a dummy account that we could log in with. That's something other founders have done in the past, and it would be more in the spirit of Show HNs:"Please make it easy for users to try your thing out, ideally without barriers such as signups or emails. You'll get more feedback that way.

Re: We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

#16

Just a thing on the sign up in the app: let me use apples private email thingy, or even better: add a “sign up with apple” button and drop the confirmation link via email. Entering my email, and then having to switch apps to press on the confirmation link and then switching back is just annoying.

I definitely hear this, but there is some tension here for us. One of the big values of Substack for writers is that it is the place where you can build your most valuable audience, which means:

1. When folks opt in, you can reach them whenever you want, unmediated by an algorithm 2. They can pay to subscribe, and you keep 90% of the economics and 3. You own your email list. You can leave Substack and take them with you.

These things create the incentive structure that allows great work to get done on Substack. But doing the secret email thing breaks #3. Part of the bargain as a reader on Substack is that you're giving your email.

Definitely hear you on the confirmation link thing.

Re: We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

#18
post #7

Any plans for a native macOS app for Substack?

Sachin here (from Substack). I for one would be stoked about a MacOS app, although it's probably not the highest priority thing right now :) Our next step within the Apple universe will most likely be to build an amazing iPad optimized experience. Right now the app works on iPad, but it's definitely not as great as it could be. A better iPad app would also be a good starting foundation for MacOS (and work on Silicon…

What will make the optimized experience on iPad amazing as opposed to just opening a tab in Safari?

Re: We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

#19
Firstly - love love love Substack. It's so simple but it's so rapidly become a place where I do so much reading. I have a few questions (mostly not about the app though, I'll have to wait for Android support to try that).

1. How did you guys manage to attract writers? I know you have been signing fronting agreements. Superficially, Substack is a (fairly basic?) blogging platform + email + payment processing system. That doesn't feel particularly hard to put together, though maybe I totally underestimate that. So what's powering Substack's growth is that you were able to get guys like Greenwald, Taibbi, Scott Alexander etc on board. How much of your growth do you think is product vs business/dealmaking?

2. You've been strong defenders of free speech, especially in the last two years where there's been a ton of censorship. Really, it's helped a lot, I've felt like Substack was one of the few places I could find rational and logical takes on things like lockdowns at a time when everyone else was losing their minds. Do you have some sort of strong philosophical take on this, or is it a sort of default because censorship takes specific effort and you're busy with growth?

3. Related to that, the pattern of tech firms being open access and supporters of free speech for some years and then later losing that as they hire more and more people (especially, new grads) seems to be a recurring one. Given you're based in San Francisco, do you have a plan to actually keep Substack the way it is, in the face of hiring employees who might demand you constantly cancel the witch-du-jour?

4. There's IMO a ton of potential for innovation with group discussions. To me, Slashdot was actually the peak of innovation in large scale anonymous forum discussions with many clever features, crowdsourced moderation, friends/foes, meta-mods etc. Do you plan to try new things with discussions, or stick to a conventional approach? Right now it's pretty basic.

Re: We’re the founders of Substack, we just launched an iOS app. AUA

#20
This probably isn't the venue for it, but your refusal to engage in the sort of content moderation the entire rest of the industry has determined "necessary" cannot be commended enough

Societal pressure on this has been intense, and your team's tweets in support of individual expression have been absolutely landmark tweets, and I am a paying customer because of it

Sincerely, thank you

Post reply on HN