Live data from Hacker News

“Compiling” Music

lilypond.org

11–20 of 45 posts

Re: “Compiling” Music

#11

Anyone else disappointed this is not about music meant to be played while compiling code ?

Not me. It’s nice and refreshing to see software that is about improving playing music for people rather than people saying “we’ve solved music with our new algorithm” (as if the thing to solve with music we’re somehow a singular aspect of the mechanics).

Re: “Compiling” Music

#13
post #7

As an untrained but interested bystander/hobbyist, the scores engraved by Lilypond are orders of magnitude better than those produced by the mainstream WYSIWYG editors, in the same "I deeply care about typography" sort of way that you get from documents produced with TeX but not Word or Google Docs. My ex-wife is a musician and a music teacher, and (especially for her teaching job) ends up writing a fair bit of sheet…

My wife is also a musician and music teacher, but I have not been able to persuade her to tackle Lilypond. (I have occasionally done projects in Lilypond for her, and the results are great, but the barrier to entry is too high for her to scale.)

What she has found much more approachable is MuseScore (https://musescore.org/). I haven't done a careful comparison of the output to see which scores better [sorry!], but it's certainly adequate for her everyday needs, and with a cheap midi keyboard as input device, it was remarkably easy to get started.

Re: “Compiling” Music

#17
post #12

Anyone else disappointed this is not about music meant to be played while compiling code ?

I was more disappointed they didn't seem to have a "Make MIDI" option; or if they did I missed it.

https://lilypond.org/doc/v2.23/Documentation/notation/creati...

Re: “Compiling” Music

#18
post #7

As an untrained but interested bystander/hobbyist, the scores engraved by Lilypond are orders of magnitude better than those produced by the mainstream WYSIWYG editors, in the same "I deeply care about typography" sort of way that you get from documents produced with TeX but not Word or Google Docs. My ex-wife is a musician and a music teacher, and (especially for her teaching job) ends up writing a fair bit of sheet…

Not quite as true anymore, as Dorico can produce output that is AT LEAST as good.

Re: “Compiling” Music

#19
Lilypond also has a guile API, and if you are not interested in the actual notation generation or at least how it looks, it can make some pretty weird and cool midi files. You can turn it into a kind of makeshift lisp Supercollider pattern generator.
Post reply on HN