Live data from Hacker News

Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

github.com

11–20 of 106 posts

Re: Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

#11
post #6

If you intend to use this, reach for the AppImage version. The AUR installation script appears to be broken, and the Flatpak version of the app is feature-incomplete (and, yunno, a Flatpak).

I use the flatpak version. What am I losing?

Unstable FS APIs, obfuscated data storage directories, and the app itself cannot generate launch shortcuts for any of your bottled programs.

Re: Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

#12

More fitting title would be "Easily manage wineprefix using environments" or "Easily manage wine prefixes in a new way" as this is just using Wine, which is what actually does the "Run Windows software and games on Linux" (current title) part. If anyone has experience, and since the repository doesn't mention it, how is Bottles different from let's say Lutris, Q4Wine and PlayOnLinux that already exists and does somet…

Not everyone understands what a 'wineprefix' even is.

Further to the point, I would hazard that the majority of linux users don't use wine because its too complex to justify the effort. Very few users for this want to know how they would configure wine to do the same thing, they just want to 'run windows software and games on linux'.

Re: Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

#13

More fitting title would be "Easily manage wineprefix using environments" or "Easily manage wine prefixes in a new way" as this is just using Wine, which is what actually does the "Run Windows software and games on Linux" (current title) part. If anyone has experience, and since the repository doesn't mention it, how is Bottles different from let's say Lutris, Q4Wine and PlayOnLinux that already exists and does somet…

Not everyone understands what a 'wineprefix' even is.

That's fair. But even the quick description of the project is "Easily manage wineprefix using environments".

Re: Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

#16
post #6

If you intend to use this, reach for the AppImage version. The AUR installation script appears to be broken, and the Flatpak version of the app is feature-incomplete (and, yunno, a Flatpak).

The download page says of Flatpak:

> This is the most supported and tested release of Bottles.

and AppImage:

> AppImage is broken, we are investigating, please use Flatpak in the meantime.

Re: Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not everyone understands what a 'wineprefix' even is.

Further to the point, I would hazard that the majority of linux users don't use wine because its too complex to justify the effort. Very few users for this want to know how they would configure wine to do the same thing, they just want to 'run windows software and games on linux'.

I don't use Wine as there is no hole in my software landscape that an exclusively Windows application will fill.

Re: Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not everyone understands what a 'wineprefix' even is.

Further to the point, I would hazard that the majority of linux users don't use wine because its too complex to justify the effort. Very few users for this want to know how they would configure wine to do the same thing, they just want to 'run windows software and games on linux'.

This.

I've been using Linux for years, and the last time I had to mess with Wine prefixes I was super confused and it ended up not working (of course). :p

CrossOver and Proton ftw.

Re: Bottles – Run Windows software and games on Linux

#19
post #6

If you intend to use this, reach for the AppImage version. The AUR installation script appears to be broken, and the Flatpak version of the app is feature-incomplete (and, yunno, a Flatpak).

> and, yunno, a Flatpak

What's wrong with Flatpak? I've had fewer problems with flatpak than with AppImage personally.

Post reply on HN