Live data from Hacker News

Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

calcalistech.com

11–20 of 370 posts

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#12

[flagged]

The “here” matters, here. If it’s America or Europe, then yes, Poland is part of NATO and the EU. Its decisions impact its partners. And if it’s invaded, coalition blood will be spilled. Mutual defence means a common interest in being worth fighting for. Add to that Warsaw’s belligerence on multiple political fronts, and the criticism is unsurprising.

More pointedly, this is current news. How are you already judging reactions?

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So it would be like domestic law enforcement (the FBI? state patrol?) using NSA-developed spyware, secretly, without court orders, against US citizens, including protestors. Whether this should surprise you I guess depends on your worldview; whether it should alarm or disturb you, especially if you are an Israeli or in Israel, I guess depends on your view of individual rights and the police.

It's more like police using Palantir or Clearview AI

It's nothing like that. Neither of those hack into people's phones.

Edit: I guess you're pointing out that the spyware was developed by a private company rather than the Israeli equivalent of the NSA, which is true.

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So it would be like domestic law enforcement (the FBI? state patrol?) using NSA-developed spyware, secretly, without court orders, against US citizens, including protestors. Whether this should surprise you I guess depends on your worldview; whether it should alarm or disturb you, especially if you are an Israeli or in Israel, I guess depends on your view of individual rights and the police.

It's more like police using Palantir or Clearview AI

Is it? I do not know anything about Israeli "Federal/State/County/Municipal" law enforcement jurisdictions to agree or disagree.

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#15
Can we stop pretending like Pegasus is not virtually everywhere?If it's not Pegasus is another tool, worse or better, foreign or domestic, from NSA,CIA,etc.Who exactly cares which entity does it as long as it's happening and laws & principles are being broken?

Vault7 was the first leak de facto proving these things existed, why the f#ck are we still surprised now, almost 5 years later, that these things are being used and there is a market here opened for politicians,private individuals, governments, etc.?

Awareness is good, but who(or better said: what institutions, what parties, etc) are you seeing advocating for more privacy, security, transparency in software and hardware, etc?

I will go one step further here beyond the simple "more privacy, security,etc." rhetoric, which i'm sure every HN user has heard to the point of ears bleeding, and I hate to say this but one cannot fully understand something until either s/he makes it, he hacks it(for the purpose of at least understanding) or becomes subject to the tool's effects.Far too many times people use something without even reading the TOS, let alone understanding the mechanisms behind the technology.At this point i have little sympathy for people who do not take the time and putting in the work of understanding a technology >for their own benefitBecause nobody who is at least semi-literate in this field was born with the knowledge, and while arguably it's our duty to point less knowledgeable people to inform themselves, we cannot tire ourselves to death by promoting (or allowing others who promote) this "usable-first, hussle-free, happy jolly" tech ecosystem and then also act surprised when the masses don't have a f*cking clue what's going on, because effectively we trained humans to become dumb monkeys with a smartphone, arguably worse.

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#16
Comment from duplicate submission:

Some of the companies in the field, in contrast to NSO, do have ethics committees to filter out obviously bad clients. Once when guidelines were described to engineers a question was asked: Would Israel itself pass the ethics committee check?

The answer was "No. But..."

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#17
People used to quip that Prussia is an army with a country rather than the other way around, it seems like if you add the modern intelligence sector that describes Israel. With all the concerns about 'Military-civil fusion ' as it's called in China or Russia I always found it funny that Israel might as well be the country that has merged both spheres most successfully but nobody really seems to care at all.

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#18

This should surprise no one since the spyware was developed by Israeli intelligence agencies.

So it would be like domestic law enforcement (the FBI? state patrol?) using NSA-developed spyware, secretly, without court orders, against US citizens, including protestors. Whether this should surprise you I guess depends on your worldview; whether it should alarm or disturb you, especially if you are an Israeli or in Israel, I guess depends on your view of individual rights and the police.

> So it would be like domestic law enforcement (the FBI? state patrol?) using NSA-developed spyware, secretly, without court orders, against US citizens, including protestors.

In the US, we already have police using Stingray interceptors without warrants (and in a similar vein but less problematic, sweeping dragnet warrants issued to cell providers), which are slightly less invasive, but relatively comparable in terms of abuse potential.

https://www.aclu.org/issues/privacy-technology/surveillance-...

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#19

People used to quip that Prussia is an army with a country rather than the other way around, it seems like if you add the modern intelligence sector that describes Israel. With all the concerns about 'Military-civil fusion ' as it's called in China or Russia I always found it funny that Israel might as well be the country that has merged both spheres most successfully but nobody really seems to care at all.

The venn diag of israel seems to be:

Military -- Government -- Corporate/tech -- Religions All seem to be seamlessly aligned within Israel..

--

I mean this is basically what all governments strive for, just that Israel has turned it into an art+science.

The amount of amazing technical innovation that comes from israel is quite stunning.

Re: Israel police uses NSO’s Pegasus to spy on citizens

#20
post #2

Once the method exists. i'd just assume its everywhere We know about Pegasus/NSO and its a fun subject to follow, but in all honesty, every engineer privy to the 0-day bank that powers it could build one of their own, or sell it to another group, and no one would know

Imagine some group that duplicates Pegasus/NSO -- compromises it but sells it AS Pegasus/NSO to unsuspecting, less-savvy nation-states and effectively uses /IT/ to infiltrate/backdoor the intelligence/LEO ops of said customer state...

Or is that what Pegasus/NSO basically already provide, as a feature?

Post reply on HN