Live data from Hacker News

Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

reuters.com

11–20 of 34 posts

Re: Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

#11
post #10

2012 Google seemed hungrier and more ambitious than 2022 Google.

This is done at a satellite level nowadays rather than fixed-wing aircraft. Microsoft/Bing did this as well and ended up spinning off their aerial collection division for that same reason, not too long after this article was published.

There's just not a huge demand for higher quality imagery by the general public, and those industries who do need higher quality/georeferenced imagery are willing to pay for it.

Re: Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

#12
Wasn't Bing Maps the first big player to offer 45-degree angle aerial imagery?

The article doesn't mention their "Bird’s Eye view" (airplane pics from 4 angles, not satellite), but I think I remember using it for some cities, before Google had it. Although I think it was short-lived. Google was focused on StreetView, iirc. After Keyhole.

Around 2009? https://www.computerworld.com/article/2468196/bing-maps--mic...

Edit: I would love to read about the history of this space, if anyone knows of a good article/blog/book.

Re: Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

#14
post #10

2012 Google seemed hungrier and more ambitious than 2022 Google.

This is done at a satellite level nowadays rather than fixed-wing aircraft. Microsoft/Bing did this as well and ended up spinning off their aerial collection division for that same reason, not too long after this article was published. There's just not a huge demand for higher quality imagery by the general public, and those industries who do need higher quality/georeferenced imagery are willing to pay for it.

I thought the biggest issue with higher quality imagery had more to do with governments than interest (privacy legislation, national security, etc).

Re: Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

#15

Wasn't Bing Maps the first big player to offer 45-degree angle aerial imagery? The article doesn't mention their "Bird’s Eye view" (airplane pics from 4 angles, not satellite), but I think I remember using it for some cities, before Google had it. Although I think it was short-lived. Google was focused on StreetView, iirc. After Keyhole. Around 2009? https://www.computerworld.com/article/2468196/bing-maps--mic... Edi…

I remember using the Microsoft aerial imagery in 2004 (that year corresponds to a certain year in high school when I used it for a class project). It wasn't "Bing" back then, but I remember it predating -- or at least having better-quality photos than -- Google Maps' aerial imagery.

Re: Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

#16
post #10

2012 Google seemed hungrier and more ambitious than 2022 Google.

This is done at a satellite level nowadays rather than fixed-wing aircraft. Microsoft/Bing did this as well and ended up spinning off their aerial collection division for that same reason, not too long after this article was published. There's just not a huge demand for higher quality imagery by the general public, and those industries who do need higher quality/georeferenced imagery are willing to pay for it.

The screensavers for Apple TV and very manual and really cool how they are made. Everything was planned. The location, exact time/day, sun placement and buildings for lens flares. One of my favorite talks at Apple was on the process to create the ones from space. An incredible amount of work went into pulling those off just for a screen saver.

Re: Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

#17

The article and the rest of the comments here act like Apple didn't do this 5 years ago. This is how Apple creates their 3D flyover feature. Microsoft also tried their hand at this as well.

Apple bought C3 Technologies in 2011, that's where they got their 3D aerial imagery processing from.

Re: Google deploying planes over cities for 3D maps (2012)

#19

Wasn't Bing Maps the first big player to offer 45-degree angle aerial imagery? The article doesn't mention their "Bird’s Eye view" (airplane pics from 4 angles, not satellite), but I think I remember using it for some cities, before Google had it. Although I think it was short-lived. Google was focused on StreetView, iirc. After Keyhole. Around 2009? https://www.computerworld.com/article/2468196/bing-maps--mic... Edi…

I remember using the Microsoft aerial imagery in 2004 (that year corresponds to a certain year in high school when I used it for a class project). It wasn't "Bing" back then, but I remember it predating -- or at least having better-quality photos than -- Google Maps' aerial imagery.

Might have been Terraserver? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terraserver.com

For a while, Terraserver was the biggest database on the web

With 5 terabytes of uncompressed image data, Microsoft TerraServer is bigger than all the HTML pages combined already on the Internet. [1998]

https://news.microsoft.com/1998/06/24/microsoft-partners-ann...

Post reply on HN