Live data from Hacker News

So called modern web developers are the culprits

unixsheikh.com

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: So called modern web developers are the culprits

#11
You missed the most important point here.

I started with RoR, also still using jQuery for "small UI improvement", and RoR has a default way to do it without boilerplate code.

But real world is not the developer's world. There's also the End user !

They want interactive , single page experience. That's the fact.

So the price to pay is what you described. Persuade and blame end user first ;)

Re: So called modern web developers are the culprits

#12
Rich Harris would probably frame this article's take as "traditionalist" — someone who cares about the traditional benefits of the web platform and sees the flaws in modern frameworks. The problem is of course that there are also benefits to modern frameworks for users as well as developers. Rich does a good job finding a middle way through both in this talk:

Have Single-Page Apps Ruined the Web? | Transitional Apps with Rich Harris, NYTimes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=860d8usGC0o

Re: So called modern web developers are the culprits

#15
Please consider making your website main content center to wrap around 80 characters in width, or even less. Anything thats less 161 characters is good.

I am very aware that I can resize my browser window to make this adjustment myself. Buf if your content is not meant to be viewed in "full screen width", do not allow it to overflow in that way. If you mean to have your content viewed in "full screen width", consider reading about line length readability issues. Also consider why scientific journals publish in the two-column format.

Regarding the content of your page. To what developer does your guidelines truly apply? To what real life setting does it give good advice? Most web development nowadays is not centered around publishing documents and or the occasional blog, but rather something more akin to applications and programs. Why is it that way? Because the web wanted to produce rich experiences for users. It became something that it was not meant for in the start. And now __it is__ that. Declaring that it is still what it started out as is simply false.

Don't get me wrong though. I perfectly see the appeal of making webpages usable in something like lynx, and have even made the effort to reach that goal in real life environments. But that is not what the "web" is for nowadays, it's something far less nerdy and appealing to us.

Re: So called modern web developers are the culprits

#16
I don't fully agree with the article, but I see everyday sites that can be so much faster by making code more optimized. Processors are getting faster and people have more RAM? Nice, let's make web sites heavier removing any optimization. Well, that's the current situation, and it's very sad.

Re: So called modern web developers are the culprits

#17
The logo on this website is 11kb for a 20x20 PNG. Running it through oxipng reduces it to 848 bytes with no difference in quality. It doesn't even need to be an image; the actual emoji would work instead and that would be 4 bytes of data.

I don't know if this is an argument that modern web developers are to blame because they do things like this, or if it shows the author isn't very aware of how to make a small website and his arguments should be taken with a dose of skepticism.

Either way, please, if the author is reading, optimize your images.

Re: So called modern web developers are the culprits

#18

Please consider making your website main content center to wrap around 80 characters in width, or even less. Anything thats less 161 characters is good. I am very aware that I can resize my browser window to make this adjustment myself. Buf if your content is not meant to be viewed in "full screen width", do not allow it to overflow in that way. If you mean to have your content viewed in "full screen width", consider…

> Please consider making your website main content center to wrap around 80 characters in width, or even less. Anything thats less 161 characters is good.

Also consider using a variable width font. They're much easier for most people to scan.

Re: So called modern web developers are the culprits

#19
Never underestimate how much people struggle with change.

These rants are trendy, I’m excited by what can be done in the browser now.

If websites were really so bloated and heavy and unusable I think they would naturally suffer for it, the problem is overstated - at least from the perspective of the average user.

Post reply on HN