Live data from Hacker News

Apple Music is the last library focused music service

erdaltoprak.com

11–20 of 246 posts

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#11
The product referred to as "Apple Music" isn't library focused. The app now known as Music and the service known as "iTunes Match" is.

Apple Music is the music as a service subscription that keeps pushing adverts in app and keeps turning itself back on even if you're not subscribed and have turned it off.

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#12

> This article explains how students do not follow the same organization paradigm based on folders and local file management. This could be, in part, attributed to the new ways young students learn, which is on online first operating systems or tablets, where by default, the local system is hidden and also where everything is done through applications. For me it was because I realized that the time I spent doing this…

It is not elitist. Really: it is just a guy trying to find an explanation to something that gets his attention. There is no adjective in it.

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#13
post #6

I prefer to buy, not rent music. Bandcamp is good for it and they sell FLAC. This is also fitting comparison to cassettes library a lot more than Apple Music where it's not your library, but Apple's. Other stores like 7digital are also good.

You can buy DRM free files from Apple. So the file is yours, transferrable, but you also can always go back and get another copy from Apple.

The combination of the iTunes Store, Apple Music, and iTunes Match is the most expansive music service offering I can think of.

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#14

> This article explains how students do not follow the same organization paradigm based on folders and local file management. This could be, in part, attributed to the new ways young students learn, which is on online first operating systems or tablets, where by default, the local system is hidden and also where everything is done through applications. For me it was because I realized that the time I spent doing this…

I was recently at an office where there were a dozen or so student workers studying for a test that required them to print out some things to bring.

The buildings internet was out, and not a single one of them realized you could save a file (while connected to cellular data) and then connect to wifi and print it.

They had only ever been taught to print directly from apps.

Sometimes it does mean they're less informed and skilled.

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#15
post #3

The more I use a streaming music service like Spotify, the more new music I find, but the shorter my musical memory becomes.

I believe memory formation is aided by multi-sensory perceptions. The experience of going somewhere to buy a CD, unwrapping it, opening it, putting it in a specific player at a certain time of the day, getting up to hit the next track button… this is a much richer set of experiences that form a much tighter web of recollection than just the audio alone. These experiences may all be totally mundane or even tiresome, but they help cement the memory of the music.

This is why you remember something more if you write it down - you get not just the memory of a fact but also the tactile experience of holding a pencil, feeling the paper, of an aching wrist…

Passively streaming someone else’s (or an algorithm’s) choice of music in the background is probably the worst possible way to build music memory because you don’t even have the association of choosing or even reading the track title.

Ritual serves a purpose.

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#16
Google Play Music was extremely album-focused, but their move over to YouTube Music has basically scrapped that.

GPM even let you modify the metadata for albums; I had used this to strip out things like "(2020 Remaster Special Gold Edition)" from album names, and to cut "bonus" tracks off of albums (nothing as fun as playing an album and then getting a two hour long spoken word interview with Quincy Jones), and finally to reorganize my classical music so that the artist was the composer and the orchestra/performer name was just munged into the album title (obviously deeper nesting would have been better, but this worked well).

Now with YTM even browsing by artist is nearly impossible, and when you do, it doesn't display the albums by that artist that you've added to your collection, it just displays everything, so there's no real way to avoid seeing 20 copies of the same album remastered at different times mixed in with "pop rock of the 90s" collections. It's just dreadful.

All I want is a music service that lets me access an unlimited virtual store and bring whatever content I want and organize it recursively by tags (i.e. when I navigate to "artist" it presents me with the ability to narrow my search by "composer" or "album" or whatever). I stick with YTM mostly because it came with free ad-free YouTube. There is no public API to talk to the service, though, so I can't even build my own frontend (although there are numerous hacks, most of which involve checking your plaintext password into a git repository, which of course means compromising your gmail account which is essentially the end of the world).

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#18
- Custom Music Artworks

- Custom Artists / Producer / Lyrics description

- Custom rules to ignore songs on random selection

- Custom rules to select equalizer per song

- Folder based navigation

- Smart Folder based playlists

- Uploading your music to the cloud and streaming them as any other song

Nails my reasoning for having stuck to it all this time as well. way easier to include my own (un-published) music, mixtapes/etc that never made it to streaming but that I have mp3s for, album art that I want to swap out, etc.

I do fear that these might all be incidental features and they eventually re-orient to mimic Spotify's approach more closely.

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#19

The product referred to as "Apple Music" isn't library focused. The app now known as Music and the service known as "iTunes Match" is. Apple Music is the music as a service subscription that keeps pushing adverts in app and keeps turning itself back on even if you're not subscribed and have turned it off.

That's not correct.

iTunes Match, which the author mentions, is responsible for exactly 1 of the features listed:

> Uploading your music to the cloud and streaming them as any other song

Everything else is part of Apple Music, the streaming service: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Music

Re: Apple Music is the last library focused music service

#20
post #7
post #3

The more I use a streaming music service like Spotify, the more new music I find, but the shorter my musical memory becomes.

If you consistently like/heart songs as you go along, put your Liked Songs list on shuffle sometime - you'll find great old gems!

I do this! It's great, but discoverability/brows-ability is lost.
Post reply on HN