Live data from Hacker News

Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 30 posts

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#11
post #8
post #4

Quite a few of the companies mentioned have traction and that is pretty impressive. I haven't seen anyone else say it but kicksend looks a lot like getcrate from sahil lavingia with facebook integration added to it.

Infact, traction could be one of the key drivers behind some of the companies getting selected into YC.

It would be interesting to get an overview on how many of the startups in the current batch had their products out 1) before getting funded by YC, 2) during YC.

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#12
post #3

My Picks for: - Most likely to succeed in a big way: Parse - Most interesting/clever (want it to succeed): Verbling - Most scary (wary of it succeeding): Double Recall

Double Recall looks like one of the very few startups that would make the world a worse place if they succeed :(

The other side of the coin is it could allow more content to remain accessible for free (given the stats advertisers are bound to pay more).

I'd rather enter brand-specified words than my credit card info.

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Double Recall looks like one of the very few startups that would make the world a worse place if they succeed :(

The other side of the coin is it could allow more content to remain accessible for free (given the stats advertisers are bound to pay more). I'd rather enter brand-specified words than my credit card info.

i do not think it is as clear-cut that brand advertisers will pay higher rates or even accept the format as they may think. sure, conversion/recall etc might be higher but company X making me do some annoying work is not exactly endearing them to me and tarnishes their brand. people are lazy.

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#14

MarketBrief sounds like a home run to me. If the product works as described it's a tremendous value proposition.

It's basically search engine spam generated from SEC docs. Adds needless verbosity to when people want the info in a concise format. When looking for actionable financial info I hate having to read through sentences when a table or graph will do. Consider why audio podcasts never really caught on for non-entertainment.

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Double Recall is as scary as the kind of ugly paywalls and interstitial ads a lot of news sites currently use. Although as a consumer I'd be bound to hit the close button on any site that used it, but that's the sites problem to try an optimise.

making me type advertiser-specified words on a mobile device to visit some site? terrible and easily worse than an interstitial.

On closer inspection I see that it is itself an interstitial, so clearly I'm wrong. Still beats a paywall.

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#17
post #3

My Picks for: - Most likely to succeed in a big way: Parse - Most interesting/clever (want it to succeed): Verbling - Most scary (wary of it succeeding): Double Recall

Double Recall looks like one of the very few startups that would make the world a worse place if they succeed :(

There are a few cases where Double Recall wouldn't be so bad. For example, if I had to pick between a Double Recall interstitial and watching a commercial before a video starts, I'd go with Double Recall. I'd also prefer them to pop under ads (which, BTW, I hadn't seen in years until I switched from FF to Chrome).

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#18
post #3

My Picks for: - Most likely to succeed in a big way: Parse - Most interesting/clever (want it to succeed): Verbling - Most scary (wary of it succeeding): Double Recall

Double Recall looks like Solve Media with a self-service-for-advertisers interface and some mobile ad units.

No real need to be afraid of Double Recall, since Solve has been in the market for a while and is doing really well. I'm sure they'll do fine if they bring on the right salespeople - it's a sales-centric business.

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#19
I'm amazed at how many "Groupon for X" startups have been popping up. In this group there is Munch On Me (restaurants) and Aisle50 (groceries), but if you look through a site like http://startupli.st/startups there are a lot of others. Opez also says they want to turn independent professionals into their own Groupons, which doesn't really equate. I presume they really mean giving the independent professionals the ability to publish their own coupons.

With as much criticism as GroupOn has received, and the suspect way they have measured their success it seems there must be a better model of comparison. Saying you want to be the LivingSocial of X would likely give a better impression.

Still, I'm not sure applying that business model to a specific industry like restaurants or groceries will lead to success. For restaurants, LivingSocial and GroupOn already give out a lot of restaurant deals. Google will soon be moving in the market also. It's quickly becoming saturated. How long can restaurants give away meals for half price?

Aisle50 is at least attacking an area that isn't really covered by existing businesses.

Re: Y Combinator Demo Day: The Ultimate Roundup

#20
post #3

My Picks for: - Most likely to succeed in a big way: Parse - Most interesting/clever (want it to succeed): Verbling - Most scary (wary of it succeeding): Double Recall

Double Recall looks like one of the very few startups that would make the world a worse place if they succeed :(

Keep in mind that Double Recall works with news publishers. The number one thing that publishers need is more money to pay for content production. Most publishers are toying with a paywall model right now. I hope they go the Double Recall route. I'd rather type in two words once a day and have an advertiser pay for my content than pull out my credit card to hop over a paywall.

So, here's the alternative. If the Double Recalls have figured out a nice sustainable way to pay for a good chunk of the journalism you enjoy, wouldn't that make the world a better place?

Post reply on HN