Live data from Hacker News

We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

nav.al

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#11
I challenge you to name a behavior that most humans do (or did) that no other animals do.

There's usually at least one other example in the animal world. Just that we may do these things in combination and so much better that the difference becomes qualitative.

I'd say the only uniquely human thing is creating fire. https://twitter.com/mluby/status/1256768920343756801 Yes, there's that Australian bird that moves fire around, so I had to narrow it to creating rather than just using fire.

(The article is lame, so focusing just on the title…)

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#12

Is the actual content behind a paywall/subscription, or those short seven paragraphs are all there is? In the latter case, this is just a statement without any proof or reasoning behind it.

Naval is very famous on Twitter for being pro-business, pro-capitalism, and anti-establishment.

https://twitter.com/naval

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#13
Humanity as a whole is qualitatively different than anything else I can think of. I think this is obvious.

But how different are humans? If you take a homo sapien in isolation and a chimpanzee in isolation (I know there's no such thing but for the sake of argument), how much difference is there really? Biologically it's not much. Even neurologically, we've basically got the same hardware with a bit more bandwidth for sensory processing, and a bit more processing power for higher order functions like planning and analysis.

The archeological record would seem to indicate that it took many tens of thousands of years for these minor fundamental differences to develop into something obviously qualitative. Whether you call these fundamental differences qualitative or quantitive to start with seems like a pretty subtle difference of perspective.

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#14
People like the author tend to think that the differences in humans vs other primates can be seen as a linear function. I'm like the author no expert on this topic but I imagine this as a exponential function. You see plenty of similar behavior in primates and humans, similar social structures, clear evidence of being capable of complex thought processes etc.

It's like the difference between transistors and a logic gate isn't big but results in much more complexity.

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#15
post #2

“We are qualitatively different. All we need to do is open our eyes. You look out your window at that beautiful ~~city~~ anthill that happens to be out there that cannot be explained by this gradual increase of biological complexity.” The only constant in our study of life is underestimating the complexity of other living things.

tl;dr: "we are special because I want it to be true, and you should too!"

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#16
post #11

I challenge you to name a behavior that most humans do (or did) that no other animals do. There's usually at least one other example in the animal world. Just that we may do these things in combination and so much better that the difference becomes qualitative. I'd say the only uniquely human thing is creating fire. https://twitter.com/mluby/status/1256768920343756801 Yes, there's that Australian bird that moves fire…

Challenge accepted. We have belief systems. We have religions, imaginary system called money, imaginary organizations called companies. These systems are not something nature gives us, but we believe them to be as real as the air we breathe.

I can’t think of an animal that has belief systems that they share with each other. I agree with the argument in the book Sapiens, that these belief systems are what allow us to collaborate and trust individuals outside of our tribe.

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#17
post #11

I challenge you to name a behavior that most humans do (or did) that no other animals do. There's usually at least one other example in the animal world. Just that we may do these things in combination and so much better that the difference becomes qualitative. I'd say the only uniquely human thing is creating fire. https://twitter.com/mluby/status/1256768920343756801 Yes, there's that Australian bird that moves fire…

Challenge accepted. We have belief systems. We have religions, imaginary system called money, imaginary organizations called companies. These systems are not something nature gives us, but we believe them to be as real as the air we breathe. I can’t think of an animal that has belief systems that they share with each other. I agree with the argument in the book Sapiens, that these belief systems are what allow us to…

Good ones. Here's what I'd say:

1. Belief/religion: there's an experiment I heard about where researchers put a banana in a tree but monkeys got shocked if they went for it. So the monkeys stopped trying to get that banana. And then the researchers gradually replaced each monkey with one who'd never been shocked. The new monkeys also never went for the tree banana, having picked up on the superstition from their group.

2. Organizations are just like packs or pods, not all of which are genetically based in nature.

3. Money is an interesting one. I'm not aware of animals even bartering or trading objects with each other, but I also wouldn't be surprised to hear it happens. It sounds like there are cases in the wild of animals trading sex for objects though. The oldest profession just got a lot older.

Re: We Are Qualitatively Different from Other Species

#18
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Challenge accepted. We have belief systems. We have religions, imaginary system called money, imaginary organizations called companies. These systems are not something nature gives us, but we believe them to be as real as the air we breathe. I can’t think of an animal that has belief systems that they share with each other. I agree with the argument in the book Sapiens, that these belief systems are what allow us to…

Good ones. Here's what I'd say: 1. Belief/religion: there's an experiment I heard about where researchers put a banana in a tree but monkeys got shocked if they went for it. So the monkeys stopped trying to get that banana. And then the researchers gradually replaced each monkey with one who'd never been shocked. The new monkeys also never went for the tree banana, having picked up on the superstition from their grou…

Don't crows trade shiny objects for food?
Post reply on HN