Live data from Hacker News

Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

dailymail.co.uk

11–20 of 337 posts

Re: Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

#12

Some of these keyword orders seem obscene in terms of how many people they target: > ("fragmentation") AND ("bomb" OR "explosive" OR "ied" OR "explosion" OR "pipebomb" OR "pipe bomb" OR "PVC bomb")

I wonder what is the minimal set of English words covering all search engine users...

Re: Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

#13

Some of these keyword orders seem obscene in terms of how many people they target: > ("fragmentation") AND ("bomb" OR "explosive" OR "ied" OR "explosion" OR "pipebomb" OR "pipe bomb" OR "PVC bomb")

I think that's the point. It gives the government an easy in to collect more data on any and all of these users, regardless of whether it is pertinent to a specific case.

Exactly. Gotta start collecting danger on every teenager who downloads the anarchist cookbook on the off chance they become a far right truck bomber in the next 20yr.

Yet every time something happens it seems like the suspect was on law enforcement's radar and they did nothing. Odd. Oh well, I'm sure a bigger data haystack to find needles in will solve that. /s

Re: Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

#15

Some of these keyword orders seem obscene in terms of how many people they target: > ("fragmentation") AND ("bomb" OR "explosive" OR "ied" OR "explosion" OR "pipebomb" OR "pipe bomb" OR "PVC bomb")

I think that's the point. It gives the government an easy in to collect more data on any and all of these users, regardless of whether it is pertinent to a specific case.

>> It gives the government an easy in to collect more data on any and all of these users, regardless of whether it is pertinent to a specific case.

That seems a little tinfoil hat to me. Like there are government people with lots of time on their hands to chase leads on things that are not related to a case. OTOH there seems to be a lot of pre-emptive searching going on, particularly in the area of terrorism related activity. On the other other hand, in that case I think we want them to foil plots before they are enacted right? It seems to be a hard set of concerns to balance. We could opt for the most privacy oriented approach, but I don't think there's much public data on what the consequences of that would be in terms of bad things happening.

Re: Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think that's the point. It gives the government an easy in to collect more data on any and all of these users, regardless of whether it is pertinent to a specific case.

Exactly. Gotta start collecting danger on every teenager who downloads the anarchist cookbook on the off chance they become a far right truck bomber in the next 20yr. Yet every time something happens it seems like the suspect was on law enforcement's radar and they did nothing. Odd. Oh well, I'm sure a bigger data haystack to find needles in will solve that. /s

[flagged]

Re: Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

#18
It may be an unpopular opinion, but I'm kind of fine with that. I mean, Google tracks everybody anyway, but there is no benefit to the society at large. But if in this way you can somehow help preventing mass murder, at least for once this tracking is put to good use. I imagine they must have a lot of false positives so probably concentrate on the worst offenders. If someone is searching for a lot of sick stuff on ways to kill people, maybe a friendly visit with a psychologist could help prevent a tragedy.

Re: Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

#19
post #12

Some of these keyword orders seem obscene in terms of how many people they target: > ("fragmentation") AND ("bomb" OR "explosive" OR "ied" OR "explosion" OR "pipebomb" OR "pipe bomb" OR "PVC bomb")

I wonder what is the minimal set of English words covering all search engine users...

.

Re: Feds order Google to track people searching certain names or details

#20
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Correction: the suspect was holding an object resembling an improvised explosive device when he was fatally shot.

Correction: the police forces that intervened reported how the suspect was holding an object resembling an improvised explosive device when he was fatally shot.

Correction: there was an officer-involved explosion when security forces investigated a suspected terrorist's kitchen / chemistry lab.
Post reply on HN