Live data from Hacker News

Wall of Sound

en.wikipedia.org

11–20 of 53 posts

Re: Wall of Sound

#11
My favorite anecdote about the Wall of Sound technique is the paralyzing effect "Be My Baby" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSPpbOGnFgk) had on Brian Wilson, founder of the Beach Boys:

> "Be My Baby" had a profound lifelong impact on the Beach Boys' founder Brian Wilson.

> When he heard "Be My Baby" for the first time through his car radio, he immediately pulled over to the side of the road and deemed it the greatest record he had ever heard. Carlin describes the song as having become "a spiritual touchstone" for Wilson, while music historian Luis Sanchez states that it formed an enduring part of Wilson's mythology, being the Spector record that "etched itself the deepest into Brian's mind ... it comes up again and again in interviews and biographies, variably calling up themes of deep admiration, a source of consolation, and a baleful haunting of the spirit."

> Music journalist David Dalton, who visited Wilson's home in 1967, said that Wilson had analyzed "Be My Baby" "like an adept memorizing the Koran." Dalton later wrote about a box of tapes he had discovered in Wilson's bedroom: "I assumed they were studio demos or reference tracks and threw one on the tape machine. It was the strangest thing ... All the tapes were of Brian talking into a tape recorder. Hour after hour of stoned ramblings on the meaning of life, color vibrations, fate, death, vegetarianism and Phil Spector."

> In the early 1970s, Wilson instructed his engineer Stephen Desper to create a tape loop consisting only of the chorus of "Be My Baby". Wilson listened to the loop for several hours in what Desper saw as "some kind of a trance." Wilson's daughter Carnie stated that during her childhood: "I woke up every morning to boom boom-boom pow! Boom boom-boom pow! Every day." Wilson told The New York Times in 2013 that he had listened to the song at least 1,000 times. In his 2016 memoir, Wilson recalled playing the song's drum intro "ten times until everyone in the room told me to stop, and then I played it ten more times." Bandmate Mike Love remembered Wilson comparing the song to Albert Einstein's theory of relativity. [0][1]

A personal anecdote: Hearing "Be my Baby" in my parents' kitchen radio, recognizing it as this wonderful piece of music I had heard somewhere before, and listening to it very happily, is one of my earliest childhood memories. My daughter, who is 2, saw the single's cover pop up in the YouTube suggestions on my laptop screen a few weeks ago and specifically demanded this song to be played multiple times (she had seen the cover a few months earlier when we played it to her, and remembered it). So maybe Brian Wilson was onto something.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Be_My_Baby

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Wilson

Re: Wall of Sound

#14
"Wall of Sound" was also an extremely awesome record/CD store on Pike St. in Seattle in the early 90s that specialized in experimental, electronic and ambient music (which I always thought was a better target for the term "wall of sound" that Spector's stuff).

Re: Wall of Sound

#15

Two of the examples of later applications of the wall of sound in the article are Jesus and Mary Chain's "Just Like Honey," and Spiritualized's "Let it Come Down," which are both fantastic albums if you are into that. The latter doesn't use the same kind of reverb, but that technique of creating a giant wash of sound was huge across the entire subgenre of shoegazer ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoegaze ), and argu…

Let it Come Down perfected the wall of sound style imo. Beautiful album.

Re: Wall of Sound

#16
post #10

If you are a Beatles Fun it's fun to listen to the records "Let it Be" and "Let it Be Naked" back to back. Let it be was produced by Phil Spector, and has a lot of the wall of sound trappings such as heavy use of effects, and heavily overdubbed string/chorus/etc parts. Let it be naked is a remixed version of the album Paul McCartney was involved in to remove much of the Spector wall of sound parts. For example listen…

fascinating. Spectors approach at times seems to share a lot in common with the Indian tradition of over-driven vocals in music. https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2vs20j/e...

> Indian tradition of over-driven vocals in music

That's interesting, any examples of that? The Reddit link doesn't give an example or explanation

Re: Wall of Sound

#17

If you are a Beatles Fun it's fun to listen to the records "Let it Be" and "Let it Be Naked" back to back. Let it be was produced by Phil Spector, and has a lot of the wall of sound trappings such as heavy use of effects, and heavily overdubbed string/chorus/etc parts. Let it be naked is a remixed version of the album Paul McCartney was involved in to remove much of the Spector wall of sound parts. For example listen…

Not quite 'wall of sound', but there was a lot of echo-y stuff added to early US Beatles albums per Dave Dexter Jr, "for the American market". I suspect there was an attempt to be "wall of sound" like, at least in part, but it was also an easy way to give yourself "production" credits on Beatles' work.

Re: Wall of Sound

#18

Two of the examples of later applications of the wall of sound in the article are Jesus and Mary Chain's "Just Like Honey," and Spiritualized's "Let it Come Down," which are both fantastic albums if you are into that. The latter doesn't use the same kind of reverb, but that technique of creating a giant wash of sound was huge across the entire subgenre of shoegazer ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shoegaze ), and argu…

Not quite sure how you can ever compare, in any way, Interpol to Joy Division!!!! Interpol were just a rock band. Joy Division are Legends.

Re: Wall of Sound

#19
post #11

My favorite anecdote about the Wall of Sound technique is the paralyzing effect "Be My Baby" ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSPpbOGnFgk ) had on Brian Wilson, founder of the Beach Boys: > "Be My Baby" had a profound lifelong impact on the Beach Boys' founder Brian Wilson. > When he heard "Be My Baby" for the first time through his car radio, he immediately pulled over to the side of the road and deemed it the grea…

Wow, after reading that legendary endorsement, I listened to it for the first time. I don’t normally think of myself as a philistine, but I’m afraid it didn’t speak to me at all. Maybe you had to be there.

Re: Wall of Sound

#20

Why do we keep deifying this guy? He's a murderer who was clever enough to give his studio techniques a catchy name.

If nothing else, it’s a useful reminder that people can do both bad things and good things, and that it’s hard to reduce someone’s life to a simple summary judgement.
Post reply on HN