Live data from Hacker News

Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

foodprocessing.com

11–20 of 81 posts

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#11

Its hard for me to understand exactly how the term "plant-based" came to be an acceptably descriptive name for a category of food. Is it so hard to just put the name of the plants in the name of the food? I think most people would be skeptical of going to a bar and ordering something off the menu that was simply called "Animal-based Wings."

It's probably because the concoction contains so many elements that it's difficult to label.

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#12

Vrimp is officially the worst branding I have heard since Kraft rebranded to Mondelez. Otherwise very cool! I've started eating Impossible or Beyond burgers wherever they have them because I like the flavor and honestly beige blend of 1000 cattle [1] isn't a particularly appetizing product. Looking forward to expanding this to eggs and, uh, vrimp. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/08/05/there...

Link without paywall: https://archive.vn/uXzaz

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#13
post #7

I remember when margarine, and other plant based fats were being touted as the healthier alternative to animal fats, and in the end, it turned out that these artificially oxidized plant oils ended up being a direct cause of heart disease. I'm afraid of products such as these for the same reason, because we have no long term health data. I'm happy to eat plants of all sorts, in their natural form. A slurry of plant fa…

Could you please cite your sources for your claims? They are rather bold and contrary to what I've learned.

A quick search readily brings up multiple articles about margarine and heart disease.

Women who eat four or more teaspoons of margarine a day have a 50 percent greater risk of developing heart disease than women who eat margarine only once a month

http://www.nytimes.com/1993/03/05/us/study-links-heart-disea...

Margarine intake and subsequent coronary heart disease in ...

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9229205

Butter vs. Margarine - Harvard Health

https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/butter-vs-mar...

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#15

I remember when margarine, and other plant based fats were being touted as the healthier alternative to animal fats, and in the end, it turned out that these artificially oxidized plant oils ended up being a direct cause of heart disease. I'm afraid of products such as these for the same reason, because we have no long term health data. I'm happy to eat plants of all sorts, in their natural form. A slurry of plant fa…

Good point. Another issue I take with these substitutes are the amount of ingredients used to make the fake counterparts. Whilst a burger is most meat, a “veggie burger” contains dozens of highly processed ones.

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#16

I remember when margarine, and other plant based fats were being touted as the healthier alternative to animal fats, and in the end, it turned out that these artificially oxidized plant oils ended up being a direct cause of heart disease. I'm afraid of products such as these for the same reason, because we have no long term health data. I'm happy to eat plants of all sorts, in their natural form. A slurry of plant fa…

I'm happy to eat plants of all sorts, in their natural form. A slurry of plant fats and proteins which approximates eggs sounds like nasty factory runoff.

I don't get this trend anyway. There are lots of perfectly good vegetarian dishes out there.

Why do we have to whore out the food industry to the tastes of meat eaters in the name of saving the planet? Can't wannabe "virtuous" meat eaters learn to eat vegetarian foods without making them look and taste like meat?

The whole thing is some form of insanity.

(For the record: I eat semi-vegetarian in that I eat less meat than most Americans and some meals are meatless. I have been accused of being vegetarian by meat-and-potatoes people and vegetarians also openly hate on me for my "crimes" of eating a sensible diet that fails to fall into either political camp.)

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#17

Its hard for me to understand exactly how the term "plant-based" came to be an acceptably descriptive name for a category of food. Is it so hard to just put the name of the plants in the name of the food? I think most people would be skeptical of going to a bar and ordering something off the menu that was simply called "Animal-based Wings."

It's a terminology used to entice those who feel like they'd need a replacement for the things they're used to, and yet might have a bad perception of the plants used in these products (like eww that tastes bad) - so it's a term for the general population.

Also these products as mostly a combination of plants, like it wouldn't be right (or maybe even legal) to say that the vEGGie is soy eggs.

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#18

Vrimp is officially the worst branding I have heard since Kraft rebranded to Mondelez. Otherwise very cool! I've started eating Impossible or Beyond burgers wherever they have them because I like the flavor and honestly beige blend of 1000 cattle [1] isn't a particularly appetizing product. Looking forward to expanding this to eggs and, uh, vrimp. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/08/05/there...

Vrimp reminds me of the McPlant from McDonalds... it almost seems intentionally bad.

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#19

if it is plants, it is not Eggs best way for a product to not work is to label it as "plant based" *insert_animal_food_name*

If you consider a chicken that only eats corn, an egg is made of corn (and air, water and whatever the chicken eats that's not her food). It's just that it's fabricated by a chicken.

Re: Nestlé to Debut Plant-Based Eggs, Shrimp

#20

Vrimp is officially the worst branding I have heard since Kraft rebranded to Mondelez. Otherwise very cool! I've started eating Impossible or Beyond burgers wherever they have them because I like the flavor and honestly beige blend of 1000 cattle [1] isn't a particularly appetizing product. Looking forward to expanding this to eggs and, uh, vrimp. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/08/05/there...

> beige blend of 1000 cattle

true, most chains are inedible, but I just can't get past the aftertaste - feels too synthetic and unhealthy.

I feel people tho tout "you won't believe it's not beef" have never tried either of them.

Post reply on HN