Live data from Hacker News

Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

blog.sigplan.org

11–20 of 49 posts

Re: Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

#13

This is very cool and I was unaware of this feature. Are there any open source libraries that perform similar tasks? I can think of a few uses for this in data cleanup as long as it can handle the input not being super clean.

As I understand it, this technology is heavily patented.

Re: Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

#14

This is very cool and I was unaware of this feature. Are there any open source libraries that perform similar tasks? I can think of a few uses for this in data cleanup as long as it can handle the input not being super clean.

Powershell has the same functionality in Convert-FromString

Re: Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

#15
post #4

> I went from searching for the hardest problem I can solve to searching for the simplest problem that will have the most impact. This is a fantastic framework to pursue when, for instance, joining a new organization. You can quickly have an outsized impact just by looking for common pain points. As a corollary, it’s very useful to spend lots of time using your own product and talking to the users!

this is something I'd pay to be addressed in most companies / institutions.

Every tool they buy (physical or digital) is always 60% fit, but adding a few bits on top would propel it above 80% and make everybody's days a bliss.

Most applications I've seen are designed for generic tasks, except that workers have a very regular set of tasks, if software could be tailored a bit to this (prefill stuff, save clicks) you cut fatigue and errors buy a huge figure.

This can have a serious social impact, last gig there were thousands of lawsuits waiting in a hall because nobody wants to type them in since the software requires to rewrite everything from scratch even if 80% of the data is identical.

Re: Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

#16

am I the only one that finds this feature distracting and unhelpful? Most of the times the recommendations are wrong, and then it's just more visual noise/keystrokes.

Do you try giving more examples? I find it usually only takes a few corrections to get it right.

You can turn it off if you don't like it. https://superuser.com/questions/766967/how-can-i-turn-off-fl...

Re: Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

#17
post #12

Fun fact: Powershell 5.1 has a `Convert-String`[1] cmdlet that is a Flash Fill implementation for CLI. You can do these inferences in Command Line. [1] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/module/microsoft...

I was hoping to browse the source for that cmdlet on github but it’s missing :-(

Re: Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

#18
post #4

> I went from searching for the hardest problem I can solve to searching for the simplest problem that will have the most impact. This is a fantastic framework to pursue when, for instance, joining a new organization. You can quickly have an outsized impact just by looking for common pain points. As a corollary, it’s very useful to spend lots of time using your own product and talking to the users!

this is something I'd pay to be addressed in most companies / institutions. Every tool they buy (physical or digital) is always 60% fit, but adding a few bits on top would propel it above 80% and make everybody's days a bliss. Most applications I've seen are designed for generic tasks, except that workers have a very regular set of tasks, if software could be tailored a bit to this (prefill stuff, save clicks) you cu…

This is one advantage of the world switching to webapps over desktop apps. It’s trivial for me to create a chrome extension that enriches or modifies the UI of a bought product.

Add an extra menu of common tasks- no problem. Add a datalist dropdown of options to a textbox where the options come from another service dynicamlly? - again no bother but usability of the vendor product went up substantially.

Re: Story of the Flash Fill Feature in Excel

#19

am I the only one that finds this feature distracting and unhelpful? Most of the times the recommendations are wrong, and then it's just more visual noise/keystrokes.

It's mostly correct in my experience, but maybe it's because I've learned what it can/can't do. And when it does what it is supposed to do, it can be very useful.
Post reply on HN