Live data from Hacker News

The British Library puts 1M newspaper pages online for free

ianvisits.co.uk

11–20 of 60 posts

Re: The British Library puts 1M newspaper pages online for free

#11
post #2

> The British Library keeps to a ‘safe date’ when determining when a newspaper can be considered to be entirely out-of-copyright, which is 140 years after the date of publication. It's depressing that copyright has been extended so far it's now longer then any single individual's possible lifetime.

This needs to change, big time.

There is almost no cash value to an article one day later, yet we completely impoverish the public domain for its sake. Not only are creators of valuable works is usually pretty distant from direct ownership anyway, there's no possible way for them to profit directly from this work. The only way a spotify-like deal works is because copyright ownership is conglomerated.

IMO, public (especially free-as-in-beer) access to newspaper archives could be pretty liberally justified on fair use grounds.

Re: The British Library puts 1M newspaper pages online for free

#14
post #2

> The British Library keeps to a ‘safe date’ when determining when a newspaper can be considered to be entirely out-of-copyright, which is 140 years after the date of publication. It's depressing that copyright has been extended so far it's now longer then any single individual's possible lifetime.

It's even worse than that, from the failed registration page:

    View 3 pages FREE when you register to help you get started
    Explore hundreds of national, regional and local titles dating from the 1700s-2000s
    Search, save and organise your favourite topics

Re: The British Library puts 1M newspaper pages online for free

#17

I wish more institutions 'tested the waters' with these copyright laws. Put a newspaper up from 100 years ago and see if anyone complains, if they do; take it down. Subtract 10 years every year until someone does complain.

I think you underestimate how assiduous copyright lawyers are. The automated systems would spot the post and prompt a complaint within minutes.

Re: The British Library puts 1M newspaper pages online for free

#18

I wish more institutions 'tested the waters' with these copyright laws. Put a newspaper up from 100 years ago and see if anyone complains, if they do; take it down. Subtract 10 years every year until someone does complain.

I think you underestimate how assiduous copyright lawyers are. The automated systems would spot the post and prompt a complaint within minutes.

Hm… I’m not convinced about the likeliness of that outcome. Automated systems like that are mostly used on YouTube/Facebook, aren’t they?

Re: The British Library puts 1M newspaper pages online for free

#19

I wish more institutions 'tested the waters' with these copyright laws. Put a newspaper up from 100 years ago and see if anyone complains, if they do; take it down. Subtract 10 years every year until someone does complain.

I think you underestimate how assiduous copyright lawyers are. The automated systems would spot the post and prompt a complaint within minutes.

Do they really have automated systems searching for 50+ year old newspapers? Probably a lot of them haven't even been digitised before, so it would be impossible to search for them in an automated way.

Re: The British Library puts 1M newspaper pages online for free

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think you underestimate how assiduous copyright lawyers are. The automated systems would spot the post and prompt a complaint within minutes.

Do they really have automated systems searching for 50+ year old newspapers? Probably a lot of them haven't even been digitised before, so it would be impossible to search for them in an automated way.

From personal experience, I can tell you that there are automated systems searching for such pieces of art.

As for newspapers, all it takes is one copyright troll to realize it's happening, and suddenly there's lawsuit settlements everywhere, making him rich.

Post reply on HN