Live data from Hacker News

Purelymail – cheap, no-nonsense email

purelymail.com

11–20 of 316 posts

Re: Purelymail – cheap, no-nonsense email

#14
Thank you for making this service available. For entrepreneurs who like to launch new ideas with custom domains, pricing models like the one here is a HUGE savings over pay-per-account (or domain) pricing found at most major email providers. Further, it's not easy making much money charging just $10/year, even if the business gets quite popular... so again, thanks for making it available.

Re: Purelymail – cheap, no-nonsense email

#15
post #3

I've been using Purelymail as my sole mail provider for over a year now (previously with Fastmail) and it has been my best email experience. It's a one-man enterprise, which may frighten some people, but I prefer boutique internet companies to the faceless monoliths. (I'd like more of the internet to be made of these small corner bodegas.)

> It's a one-man enterprise

For this reason alone, I can't trust that they meet all the security considerations email providers now have as a consequence of all the services effectively delegating either secondary or primary authentication factors (or reset mechanisms) to email.

Re: Purelymail – cheap, no-nonsense email

#17
post #3

I've been using Purelymail as my sole mail provider for over a year now (previously with Fastmail) and it has been my best email experience. It's a one-man enterprise, which may frighten some people, but I prefer boutique internet companies to the faceless monoliths. (I'd like more of the internet to be made of these small corner bodegas.)

> It's a one-man enterprise, which may frighten some people

Email is super critical for most people these days (eg. 2FA). That sounds like a really scary bus-factor [1] risk, especially considering data is encrypted at rest.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_factor

Re: Purelymail – cheap, no-nonsense email

#18
Screenshots of the mail UI would be awesome.

On the drawbacks blurb, it mentions potential deliverability issues and says they’re usually resolved in a day or two. Through blog entries by mailchimp, I've read this is an extremely hard problem to solve and like playing whack-a-mole. How true is that? For example, I’ve read that trying to host your own email on digital ocean is pointless, which is understandable because of the amount of spam likely coming out of their subnets. Is this service downplaying the issue?

Re: Purelymail – cheap, no-nonsense email

#19
post #3

I've been using Purelymail as my sole mail provider for over a year now (previously with Fastmail) and it has been my best email experience. It's a one-man enterprise, which may frighten some people, but I prefer boutique internet companies to the faceless monoliths. (I'd like more of the internet to be made of these small corner bodegas.)

From the FAQ > Occasionally, obscure email servers will block emails sent through us.

Maybe it's good for personal use or as a throwaway email, but it is not good for main business email. Certainly not a replacement for Gmail or Fastmail kinds. Because you expect the email service to have 24/7 availability and near-perfect email delivery and receiving.

> It's a one-man enterprise

A person can get sick or just wish to take a holiday for a couple of weeks. What happens when service goes down or I need customer support urgently?

Re: Purelymail – cheap, no-nonsense email

#20

Screenshots of the mail UI would be awesome. On the drawbacks blurb, it mentions potential deliverability issues and says they’re usually resolved in a day or two. Through blog entries by mailchimp, I've read this is an extremely hard problem to solve and like playing whack-a-mole. How true is that? For example, I’ve read that trying to host your own email on digital ocean is pointless, which is understandable becaus…

The webmail is RoundCube with Classic, Larry or Elastic skins.

I have had a handful of deliverability issues, but every one of these has been due to one of those awful "enterprise network solutions" that does everything wrong.

Post reply on HN