Live data from Hacker News

The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

nytimes.com

11–20 of 29 posts

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#11
post #9

I grew up on the East Coast, so my first trip to Big Basin Redwoods State Park [0] was awe-inspiring. I'm glad to see this tree surviving so far from its preferred environment. [0] http://www.parks.ca.gov/?page_id=540

Big Basin is mostly closed just now after the CZU fire, but I can recommend Henry Woods [1] if you are visiting Mendocino.

[1] https://www.parks.ca.gov/?page_id=438

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#12
post #3

It never occurred to me that Palo Alto means Tall Stick(Tree) even though I knew Alto meant tall.

Same! Even though I knew the words palisades, impale, the phrase "beyond the pale" (beyond the fence).

All the same derivation.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pale#Etymology_2_2

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#14
post #13

I live right next to this tree. Interestingly, the city of Palo alto also has some electrical plumbing attached to this tree. Not sure if it's for the tree's health or just some connections for the nextdoor train tracks.

The article actually talks about a misting system set up a few decades ago for the tree since coastal redwoods can take in a lot of their water from fog. It didn't make clear what the current status of that system was or I missed that part.

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#16
post #3

It never occurred to me that Palo Alto means Tall Stick(Tree) even though I knew Alto meant tall.

Pole in English = Paal in Dutch = Palo in Spanish

Not really, "palo" means "stick" in spanish.

Pole = Poste.

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#17
post #7

I used to live in a condo building directly across the street from El Palo Alto. Walked by it every morning. Like the article says, it's in a small park right next to the Caltrain tracks, and you probably wouldn't take notice of it unless you already knew about it. I didn't know a lot of the history that this article provided, though... I love the thought of a >1k year old living thing just standing there inconspicuo…

Ditto! Man that was a great spot to live so much to walk to nearby and you have a caltrain stop right there.

I remember walking through that tiny park reading the usual signs when I read the Palo Alto one. Its very unassuming and I was so surprised I had to look it up and verify I had it right.

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pole in English = Paal in Dutch = Palo in Spanish

Not really, "palo" means "stick" in spanish. Pole = Poste.

"Pole" in English is derived [1] from the Latin palus (from whence "palo"). The archaic English word "pale" (also meaning stick or stake) survives in the expression "beyond the pale."

[1]https://www.etymonline.com/word/pole

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#19
post #7

I used to live in a condo building directly across the street from El Palo Alto. Walked by it every morning. Like the article says, it's in a small park right next to the Caltrain tracks, and you probably wouldn't take notice of it unless you already knew about it. I didn't know a lot of the history that this article provided, though... I love the thought of a >1k year old living thing just standing there inconspicuo…

Walked by it every day! I remember reading that if high speed rail ever does materialize (and that's a big, big if..) they'd have to do something about the track positions and the tree.

Re: The Unlikely Survival of the 1,081 Year-Old Redwood El Palo Alto

#20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not really, "palo" means "stick" in spanish. Pole = Poste.

"Pole" in English is derived [1] from the Latin palus (from whence "palo"). The archaic English word "pale" (also meaning stick or stake) survives in the expression "beyond the pale." [1] https://www.etymonline.com/word/pole

That's a neat etymological fact I wasn't completely aware of, but in today's spanish "palo" doesn't mean "pole" nor "poste", it just means "stick".

I believe we are talking about two different things, because I'm only clarifying the current meaning of the word.

Post reply on HN