Live data from Hacker News

Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

digiday.com

11–20 of 69 posts

Re: Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

#11
post #8
post #6

It's like an addict who tells themselves "I need to quit sometime" but constantly puts off actually quitting.

Google Drive itself uses third-party cookies. You can't download files from Google Drive without enabling them, for some reason.

I think many people will agree that this is just terrible engineering and there are many ways to authenticate users who download files without the use of 3rd-party cookies. Literally every other cloud storage provider was able to figure that one out.

Re: Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

#13

So for two more years, Chrome will be the only major web browser to provide no reasonable expectation of privacy and security. Nobody should still be using it by 2023.

It's amazing how this Google troll is allowed to repeatedly post negative comments about Google without any repercussions.

Re: Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

#14
> We believe the web community needs to come together to develop a set of open standards to fundamentally enhance privacy on the web, giving people more transparency and greater control over how their data is used.

> In order to do this, we need to move at a responsible pace. This will allow sufficient time for public discussion on the right solutions, continued engagement with regulators, and for publishers and the advertising industry to migrate their services.

> By ensuring that the ecosystem can support their businesses without tracking individuals across the web, we can all ensure that free access to content continues.

This proves Google's consumer privacy strategy is all smoke and show. It should come to no ones surprise they choose to follow the money (ads). Apple continues to improve privacy on Safari with every major update and Google is still sitting on the sidelines.

https://blog.google/products/chrome/updated-timeline-privacy...

Re: Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

#16
Sounds like a great reason for everyone to stop using Chrome. This is a capability that's been in Firefox and Safari for awhile now.

We're getting back to a point where the dominant browser is focused on rent-extraction over user-focused design and features, and alternatives are superior in pretty much every way other than bug-compat with the dominant browser (e.g. same thing we had in the IE6 days).

There's no reason anyone who's technically inclined should be using Chrome as a daily-driver at this point. Their interference in ad-blocker extensions should have been enough, this should be the nail in the coffin.

Re: Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

#18
post #15

You can opt into blocking third party cookies now. > Select Settings > Site Settings > Cookies and site data. > Select Block third-party cookies.

For quick access, you can copy/paste this into the Omnibar:

chrome://settings/cookies

Just turned it on myself. Thank you, OP!

Re: Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

#19
post #16

Sounds like a great reason for everyone to stop using Chrome. This is a capability that's been in Firefox and Safari for awhile now. We're getting back to a point where the dominant browser is focused on rent-extraction over user-focused design and features, and alternatives are superior in pretty much every way other than bug-compat with the dominant browser (e.g. same thing we had in the IE6 days). There's no reaso…

Chrome still lets you block third party cookies. Not with an extension or some low level tweak; it's just in the settings.

Re: Google extends third party cookie deadline until late 2023

#20
post #16

Sounds like a great reason for everyone to stop using Chrome. This is a capability that's been in Firefox and Safari for awhile now. We're getting back to a point where the dominant browser is focused on rent-extraction over user-focused design and features, and alternatives are superior in pretty much every way other than bug-compat with the dominant browser (e.g. same thing we had in the IE6 days). There's no reaso…

Google should be barred from making a web browser. The DOJ should come down hard on this behavior.

Not only is this monopolistic, but it's destroying the web and turning our privacy situation into a trash fire.

They're making this 3rd party cookie decision at the behest of their adsense unit, and it's decisions like these that are infectious across product boundaries. AMP, no URL, increasingly unilateral and opaque HTML standards that serve to push ads, ...

Google has been so lazy at innovation in other areas that they can't afford to lose Chrome. It's a key part of their fragile moat. They'll defend it to the death.

Nevertheless, these two products should not be the same company.

I want Google to succeed, but not like this.

Post reply on HN