Live data from Hacker News

Punchd has been acquired by Google

getpunchd.com

11–20 of 27 posts

Re: Punchd has been acquired by Google

#11

Super Secure Patent-pending technology guarantees the integrity of your loyalty program. GPS triangulation, velocity analysis, and statistical variation keep things secure. Each venue gets one static QR code. A bit of fraud prevention based on location and statistical analysis does not seem "super secure" to me but perhaps i am missing something.

"Super Secure" is obviously marketing copy and not an existing security spec. The actual security is explained below.

Re: Punchd has been acquired by Google

#12
post #6

Did an Ask HN on this a few months ago ( http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1897331 ). Knew the responses would be pretty biased, but it was still encouraging. Glad I heeded you all.

Wow, no joke. Really cool to see Cal Poly grads doing big stuff, especially from the Android Dev classes. Missed that one by a quarter :)

why do u put a happy face that you missed it?

Re: Punchd has been acquired by Google

#13

Super Secure Patent-pending technology guarantees the integrity of your loyalty program. GPS triangulation, velocity analysis, and statistical variation keep things secure. Each venue gets one static QR code. A bit of fraud prevention based on location and statistical analysis does not seem "super secure" to me but perhaps i am missing something.

I wonder why they do one QR code instead of letting them print out a week's worth of QR codes in advance or something actually secure.

Re: Punchd has been acquired by Google

#17

Super Secure Patent-pending technology guarantees the integrity of your loyalty program. GPS triangulation, velocity analysis, and statistical variation keep things secure. Each venue gets one static QR code. A bit of fraud prevention based on location and statistical analysis does not seem "super secure" to me but perhaps i am missing something.

"Super Secure" is obviously marketing copy and not an existing security spec. The actual security is explained below.

Can you link to the "actual security". I don't see it below.

Regardless, any small business with a loyalty program would pick up on some guy that comes in repeatedly for free stuff. Their reports would probably indicate it too. An electronic version like this is definitely more secure than a punchcard, which can easily be gamed by going to your local art store.

Re: Punchd has been acquired by Google

#18

Super Secure Patent-pending technology guarantees the integrity of your loyalty program. GPS triangulation, velocity analysis, and statistical variation keep things secure. Each venue gets one static QR code. A bit of fraud prevention based on location and statistical analysis does not seem "super secure" to me but perhaps i am missing something.

I wonder why they do one QR code instead of letting them print out a week's worth of QR codes in advance or something actually secure.

That's definitely an option, but from a usability standpoint for business owners it's a nightmare (as they have to keep track of many things already). Seems easy enough, user study showed it was a pain point.

I agree current implementation isn't exactly ideal, but we'll probably find a good compromise soon.

Re: Punchd has been acquired by Google

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Super Secure" is obviously marketing copy and not an existing security spec. The actual security is explained below.

Can you link to the "actual security". I don't see it below. Regardless, any small business with a loyalty program would pick up on some guy that comes in repeatedly for free stuff. Their reports would probably indicate it too. An electronic version like this is definitely more secure than a punchcard, which can easily be gamed by going to your local art store.

We started around the same time in Velocity, Waterloo but with a more secure patent-pending approach:

http://vimeo.com/22926049

hardware took ages to develop.. It still doesn't work for BB.. ;)

Post reply on HN