Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

techcrunch.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#11

Post by nickb »

jrockway wrote: post #9
briansmith wrote: post #3

The reason that Japanese people access the internet on their phones more than from computers is that they spend a huge amount of time on trains where there is nothing else to do. 1-2 hour train commutes each way are commonplace. They are not supposed to be looking around at other people on the train and they aren't supposed to talk on the phone. Most of the time you will be standing up because there are no seats avai…

What else are you going to do if you spend 2-4 hours a day standing still in one spot trying not to look at anyone? Read a book? And indeed, there is about an even split between people reading books and people playing with their mobiles. Remember that a lot of the trains run underground, and not every line has a cell phone signal for every provider. I think the reason for the popularity of the mobile Internet is that…

The two are not mutually exclusive.

http://www.wired.com/culture/lifestyle/news/2007/01/72329

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#12

Post by d0mine »

briansmith wrote: post #3

The reason that Japanese people access the internet on their phones more than from computers is that they spend a huge amount of time on trains where there is nothing else to do. 1-2 hour train commutes each way are commonplace. They are not supposed to be looking around at other people on the train and they aren't supposed to talk on the phone. Most of the time you will be standing up because there are no seats avai…

The main reason is the complexity of Japanese language, namely technical barriers that existed for text entry and displaying the characters on personnel computer in 80s-90s (http://blog.gatunka.com/2008/05/05/why-japan-didnt-create-th...)

Thus there is a strong culture of complex specialized gadgets and a weak general-purpose personal computer culture.

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#13

Post by nickb »

stcredzero wrote: post #10
babul wrote: post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The geographical size has its advantages but it is more about the culture and people. The society in Japan embraces technology (and the change and progress it usually entails) more readily than almost anywhere else, so such continuous early adoption creates the virtuous circles that continue to feed it. If the markets in other small countries (especially those with similar economies) behaved in the same way, the dema…

Japanese culture still seems to prize intelligence, whereas places like the US require you to hide it some of the time. It's almost like they're an entire nation of nerds.

As someone who knows a lot about Japan, I can tell you that you're partially wrong. Japanese culture prizes intelligence as much as Western culture: only in those circles that would appreciate it.

Read up on traditional Japanese saying: "The Nail that Sticks Up will be hammered down." and conformity of Japanese culture.

http://www.snorko.org/cyberwrite/eng103/students/dianec.html

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#14

Post by briansmith »

mtw wrote: post #7
briansmith wrote: post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Either you have to let the carriers control things or you have to have regulation. Without regulation, the carriers are free to do what they want since they own the network. To force them to do things they don't want to do, you have to have regulation. If regulation is stifling innovation then you can abolish the regulations. But, that just means everybody is free to do what they want, and you are back to where you s…

"Either you have to let the carriers control things or you have to have regulation" Apple proved this wrong, and I expect Google's android to do the same (well if they deliver what they announced)

"Apple proved this wrong"

Where is Skype for iPhone? Why isn't tethering built into the iPhone? Why did they pull Netshare from the app store?

"I expect Google's android to do the same."

First, what can Android do that Windows Mobile and Symbian haven't already been doing for years? Android is just Google's attempt to get its advertisements displayed more often on mobile devices. It is the same thing that every advertising company has been trying to do in Japan, the US, and everywhere else ever since it's been possible to advertise on phones.

Authorized retailers for AT&T/Verizon/etc. cannot sell any devices that aren't approved by the respective carrier. If the carrier doesn't approve the Android devices then they can only be sold at stores that don't sell service contracts. Those independent stores are not successful in the US, because everybody wants a phone tied to a service contract so that the cost of the phone is subsidized. If the carriers don't subsidize Android phones they will be priced out of the market.

Further, any carrier can block any device. IMEI numbers are allocated in blocks and it isn't hard to identify the model based on the IMEI number. Without regulation ("net neutrality") they can also block any application or any protocol from operating on their network.

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#15

Post by dats »

stcredzero wrote: post #10
babul wrote: post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The geographical size has its advantages but it is more about the culture and people. The society in Japan embraces technology (and the change and progress it usually entails) more readily than almost anywhere else, so such continuous early adoption creates the virtuous circles that continue to feed it. If the markets in other small countries (especially those with similar economies) behaved in the same way, the dema…

Japanese culture still seems to prize intelligence, whereas places like the US require you to hide it some of the time. It's almost like they're an entire nation of nerds.

I've noticed intelligence is respected but conformity is respected much, much more.

From a recent article titled "Why Apple isn't Japanese"

"One notorious case in point involves Shuji Nakamura, the brilliant scientist who invented a revolutionary energy-saving blue-diode light source only to find himself mired in years of litigation as he struggled to extract royalty payments from the company that had profited from his invention. Nakamura ultimately abandoned Japan for California. Fasol recalls asking scientists at the University of Tokyo if they considered his departure a blow. " 'No, not at all,' they told me. 'It might be good to have someone more ordinary'." "

http://www.newsweek.com/id/73236/output/print

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#16

Post by stcredzero »

dats wrote: post #15
stcredzero wrote: post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Japanese culture still seems to prize intelligence, whereas places like the US require you to hide it some of the time. It's almost like they're an entire nation of nerds.

I've noticed intelligence is respected but conformity is respected much, much more. From a recent article titled "Why Apple isn't Japanese" "One notorious case in point involves Shuji Nakamura, the brilliant scientist who invented a revolutionary energy-saving blue-diode light source only to find himself mired in years of litigation as he struggled to extract royalty payments from the company that had profited from h…

There's a lot of conformity in the US as well. It's often harnessed by marketers.

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#17

Post by mtw »

briansmith wrote: post #14
mtw wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Either you have to let the carriers control things or you have to have regulation" Apple proved this wrong, and I expect Google's android to do the same (well if they deliver what they announced)

"Apple proved this wrong" Where is Skype for iPhone? Why isn't tethering built into the iPhone? Why did they pull Netshare from the app store? "I expect Google's android to do the same." First, what can Android do that Windows Mobile and Symbian haven't already been doing for years? Android is just Google's attempt to get its advertisements displayed more often on mobile devices. It is the same thing that every adver…

The Apple "platform" is not 100% free (you can't do yet voip or tethering), but for the first time, mobile software developers can deploy easily applications without asking permissions from carriers.

Also, your web browsing experience on the iPhone is independent from the carrier. For instance, on any other carrier, they cram their links and "preferred partners" on starting page.

Again, I agree there are limitations. If you are looking for complete "freedom", have a look at openmoko.

"everybody wants a phone tied to a service contract so that the cost of the phone is subsidized" disagree. look at prepaid phones.

Re: Japan’s super-advanced mobile web: Too unique to serve as a global blueprint?

#18

Post by briansmith »

mtw wrote: post #17
briansmith wrote: post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Apple proved this wrong" Where is Skype for iPhone? Why isn't tethering built into the iPhone? Why did they pull Netshare from the app store? "I expect Google's android to do the same." First, what can Android do that Windows Mobile and Symbian haven't already been doing for years? Android is just Google's attempt to get its advertisements displayed more often on mobile devices. It is the same thing that every adver…

The Apple "platform" is not 100% free (you can't do yet voip or tethering), but for the first time, mobile software developers can deploy easily applications without asking permissions from carriers. Also, your web browsing experience on the iPhone is independent from the carrier. For instance, on any other carrier, they cram their links and "preferred partners" on starting page. Again, I agree there are limitations.…

Even with the iPhone, carriers have the final say. If AT&T doesn't like an application, it can just ask Apple to remove it from the AppStore. Or, they could just block the network access that the application needs to work (e.g. blacklist websites that the application contacts).

It is true that the iPhone doesn't come with vendor customizations, which is nice. However, none of the AT&T phones I have purchased have been extensively customized either.

Most prepaid phones are subsidized by the carriers that distribute them (e.g. AT&T GoPhone), and those phones are locked to that carrier and have customized firmware. In the US, there are very few OEM phone sales. That is why you only see Nokia stores in the very biggest cities here (Chicago, New York, LA); I don't think there are any Sony-Ericsson shops in the US at all. OEM phones just don't sell.

Post reply on HN