Live data from Hacker News

Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

mmodata.blogspot.com

11–20 of 43 posts

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#11

You know what the best way to protest a game is? Stop playing for a while and send an email. I know this sounds absurdly little, but look at it this way: If you're out doing other things, you might find something you like and -never come back-. This scares the bejeezus out of game developers who exist solely on the fact that people are addicted. If their playerbase actually went and did other things, they couldn't ke…

In EVE (and many other MMOs), unsubscribing doesn't immediately deactivate your account, it just stops adding time to it. Quite a few players have unsubscribed. By using their remaining time to protest ingame, they're ensuring that other players see their protest, not just CCP.

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#12

When I played Runescape, we had similar massive riots over the removal of free trade and the old pvp system (wilderness pking). The pkers were on average decidedly less mature than the average player, so there was really poor communication from them, but also from the company Jagex, who struggled to explain the 'why' behind the changes. Can anyone who plays Eve comment on how the company is responding?

I'm a (retired) director of one of the larger corps in EVE, and I've been discussing the points of contention with members today.

Most of it stems from the fact that those rioting feel the prioritization of the walking-in-stations expansion and the addition "vanity items" is poor judgement. There are bugs, missing features, and new changes that are viewed by the rioters to be of far greater importance than the time spent on this latest update.

There's a semi-offical "voice of the riot" here:http://eve.beyondreality.se/NeXCQResponse.html

And CCP's response here: http://www.eveonline.com/devblog.asp?a=blog&bid=932

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#13

When I played Runescape, we had similar massive riots over the removal of free trade and the old pvp system (wilderness pking). The pkers were on average decidedly less mature than the average player, so there was really poor communication from them, but also from the company Jagex, who struggled to explain the 'why' behind the changes. Can anyone who plays Eve comment on how the company is responding?

I'm a (retired) director of one of the larger corps in EVE, and I've been discussing the points of contention with members today. Most of it stems from the fact that those rioting feel the prioritization of the walking-in-stations expansion and the addition "vanity items" is poor judgement. There are bugs, missing features, and new changes that are viewed by the rioters to be of far greater importance than the time s…

And now that you've read that, I'll keep my opinion separate: I think the riots are out of line and unnecessary. CCP does need to do a better job at addressing the complaints (requests are listed here http://wiki.eveonline.com/en/wiki/November_2010_Prioritizati...) and explaining their prioritization... but I think the riots have trouble focusing on the real issue, which is simply communication.

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#15
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of the big problems with 'stop playing' protests is that gamers have to pay for a month of playtime in advance, and in many cases, they pay in 3-12 month intervals to save money. This is the case for World of Warcraft subscriptions, for example - they give you a discount if you pay up front. If you stop playing after you already paid, the company isn't really going to suffer any immediate impact, and any visible…

Also, Eve especially has problems with continuous commitments to your alliance. No spaceholding alliance would give up defending their space to protest vanity monocles and the possibility of microtransactions.

Hahaha, this is so fucking telling. I love how in depth Eve is because it makes players mirror real world issues.

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#16
post #2

Live video of the Jita protest: http://en.justin.tv/deamosseraph It's really quite impressive! Edit: there's another one at Amarr, http://www.justin.tv/dnah_pmip#/w/1381178160/2 but it's not as big.

I wonder if Concorde will destroy their ships and camp whatever station they're around, forcing them to stay in the same place for bloody hours, deprived of resources needed to stay alive.

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#17
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of the big problems with 'stop playing' protests is that gamers have to pay for a month of playtime in advance, and in many cases, they pay in 3-12 month intervals to save money. This is the case for World of Warcraft subscriptions, for example - they give you a discount if you pay up front. If you stop playing after you already paid, the company isn't really going to suffer any immediate impact, and any visible…

Also, Eve especially has problems with continuous commitments to your alliance. No spaceholding alliance would give up defending their space to protest vanity monocles and the possibility of microtransactions.

Obvious solution would be to use empire/hauling alts. Although I noticed a fair bit of laser fire in the live feed as well, missles seemed to be a minority.

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#18
> for people not familiar with EVE: Jita is the main trade hub of the game. Since EVE only has one server, that makes Jita the de-facto capital of the game, and it's main system. There are other simmilar (but smaller) trade hubs (Amarr and Rens, among others), and those are seeing protests as well. Those systems have a hard limit to their population, and when it's capped, the gates close. The protests seem to have capped both Amarr and Jita, and are therefore stopping people from entering the picketed systems, slowing down the player-driven market inside them.

http://www.ps3trophies.com/forums/pc/63552-eve-online-virtua...

Re: Thousands of EVE online players riot over microtransactions

#20
post #19

Really, people are getting this raged about shit in an online game? Take to the streets, my friends. Fight for the real world, not an imaginary one.

If your imaginary world is all you have, is it not your real world?

After a few years working in academia, I have a simple statement:

That which pays thy bills is the real world.

It can correspond to another statement: that which feeds thy mouth is the real world, too.

I can't eat virtual bread. It's not the real world.

Post reply on HN