Live data from Hacker News

Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides

bbc.com

11–20 of 502 posts

Re: Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides

#11
post #8

This pales in comparison to some of the stories I've heard from women regarding the sexually aggressive and harassing behavior they've experienced from (always male) Uber drivers, often on the way home late at night (where the driver gets to see their home address). This isn't apparently a firing offense at Uber.

Perhaps, but that's entirely off-topic

Is it? I think it falls squarely on the topic of "Uber drivers breaking the law and Uber choosing to not deal with it (to the detriment of riders) 'because contractors'", that is, just what TFA is about.

Re: Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides

#13
post #7

> It rejected Uber's claim that the company itself was not liable, because, it argued, its drivers had the status of contractors rather than employees. I feel like money would be better spent raising awareness of service dogs and dealing with fraudulent (they do call it fraud, right?) service dogs than fining Uber.

Yes, makes no sense that anyone can register their pet as emotional support.

Re: Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides

#15
I think anyone who has taken Uber and Lyft a lot knows that they allow drivers to abuse the system for their benefit, with no recourse for riders.

A few incidents that have bothered me: 1. Having an Uber refuse to take me to the airport from downtown Chicago 2. Lyft not giving me an automatic refund for a pickup in SOMA when the driver had been heading down 101 for 10 minutes and was showing no signs of turning around. 3. Every Uber driver cancelling rides at LAX to force surge pricing.

I'm not suprised that Uber drivers do not want to deal with riders with disabilities. Since Uber and Lyft are not profitable they can't even afford to kick any drivers off the platform other than drivers that pose a risk of physical danger to passengers.

Until Uber and Lyft implement a system that actually can result in negative consequences for unethical drivers, I have no sympathy for any losses these companies incur.

Re: Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides

#16
post #2

Does an uber driver know when they accept a ride that the rider has a dog with them?

Presumably not. Even if they did, what should they do with that information? Service dogs have special status.

How does this work for workers with dog allergies?

Re: Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides

#17
post #2

Does an uber driver know when they accept a ride that the rider has a dog with them?

For service animals, it doesn't matter unless there is a specific reason.

https://www.adalive.org/episode5_qas#14

> Service animals are always permitted to accompany their users in any private or public transportation vehicle or facility. This means that they must be allowed to ride with the person with a disability.

> One of the most common misunderstandings about service animals is that they are limited to being guide dogs for persons with visual impairments. But dogs used as service animals are trained to assist people with a wide variety of disabilities, including individuals with hearing and mobility impairments.

> One more thing: charging extra fees to carry a service animal and an individual with a disability would also be a violation of the ADA.

---

https://www.transit.dot.gov/what-americans-disabilities-act-...

> DOT ADA regulation 49 C.F.R. Section 37.167(d) requires transit entities to permit service animals to accompany individuals with disabilities in vehicles and facilities.

The cited part is https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/49/37.167

That section reads:

> (d) The entity shall permit service animals to accompany individuals with disabilities in vehicles and facilities.

Re: Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Presumably not. Even if they did, what should they do with that information? Service dogs have special status.

How does this work for workers with dog allergies?

Service dogs are bred to be hypoallergenic.
Post reply on HN