Live data from Hacker News

Amazon rainforest plots sold via Facebook Marketplace ads

bbc.com

11–20 of 106 posts

Re: Amazon rainforest plots sold via Facebook Marketplace ads

#11
post #2

I was wondering what the trick is, as selling a place without holding its title may not command a very high price, even if you clear it and make it ready for business - for cattle ranching in the case of the rainforest. Turns out it's similar to the concept of adverse occupation: > Another factor driving the illegal land market is the expectation of amnesty. > Mr Alves revealed he was working with others to lobby pol…

can we just stop shoehorning blockchain into everything

Re: Amazon rainforest plots sold via Facebook Marketplace ads

#13
> Facebook said it was "ready to work with local authorities", but indicated it would not take independent action of its own to halt the trade.

Huh? If the ads were for firearms or child slaves, would Facebook's response also be that it was ready to work with local authorities, but would not take independent action?

So how can Facebook take this kind of flippant approach to this, but not on other items? The, not even hypocrisy, but just complete lack of fundamental human decency and respect is revolting.

Re: Amazon rainforest plots sold via Facebook Marketplace ads

#14

> Facebook said it was "ready to work with local authorities", but indicated it would not take independent action of its own to halt the trade. Huh? If the ads were for firearms or child slaves, would Facebook's response also be that it was ready to work with local authorities, but would not take independent action? So how can Facebook take this kind of flippant approach to this, but not on other items? The, not even…

Children and guns can be trafficked.

Re: Amazon rainforest plots sold via Facebook Marketplace ads

#18

> Facebook said it was "ready to work with local authorities", but indicated it would not take independent action of its own to halt the trade. Huh? If the ads were for firearms or child slaves, would Facebook's response also be that it was ready to work with local authorities, but would not take independent action? So how can Facebook take this kind of flippant approach to this, but not on other items? The, not even…

Selling children and guns (at least in most parts of the world) is just outright prohibited. Selling land isn't.

You don't need to figure out whether it is an illegal or legal child sale as all child selling is illegal. Selling land in itself is not illegal.

Re: Amazon rainforest plots sold via Facebook Marketplace ads

#19

> Facebook said it was "ready to work with local authorities", but indicated it would not take independent action of its own to halt the trade. Huh? If the ads were for firearms or child slaves, would Facebook's response also be that it was ready to work with local authorities, but would not take independent action? So how can Facebook take this kind of flippant approach to this, but not on other items? The, not even…

They only block Trump ... everything else takes legal actions...

Re: Amazon rainforest plots sold via Facebook Marketplace ads

#20

This is one of those rare times I agree with facebook. Why is this Facebook's problem? Sounds like Brazil should be enforcing their laws better. Facebook hosts for-sale postings, how reasonable is it for them to vet every post against scams and illegality?

If you follow this line of thought, the conclusion seems to be that if Facebook were to run ads for illegal drugs, explosives, or humans, it would simply be an indication that some country should be enforcing it's laws better. And Facebook would be totally in clear to continue showing those ads.

This seems obviously wrong.

Post reply on HN