Live data from Hacker News

Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

petapixel.com

11–20 of 36 posts

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#11
Several other commenters seem to have missed a detail from the article: in every single one of these tests the software is running natively on both the Dell and Intel Mac and entirely in emulation on the M1.

That said, we already have had plenty of these comparisons done, I don't think there is anything revolutionary here, this is more an article targeted towards people who do a specific task (photography) than tech news in general.

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#12

> this changes everything > As you can see, M1 Mac beats Intel Mac in every Lightroom benchmark across the board Yeah, by a relatively small amount according to your own charts... It's still impressive, not exactly earth shattering.

Running through emulation and on an entry level first generation machine that is significantly cheaper

I wouldn't call a $2,300 device "entry level".

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#13

> this changes everything > As you can see, M1 Mac beats Intel Mac in every Lightroom benchmark across the board Yeah, by a relatively small amount according to your own charts... It's still impressive, not exactly earth shattering.

… while consuming far less power, while being passively cooled, and while not even running native code!

I think Apple is a huge threat to general purpose computing freedom, and I refuse to use their products. But hats off to their M1!

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#14
I think a lot of people who have been reflexively buying new MacBook Pros every couple years should do themselves a favor and seriously consider a MacBook Air this time around. It's the same performance most of the time, and for tasks longer than 5 minutes, thermal throttling will only reduce performance by ~20% or so - for many that's still, plenty, plenty fast, when the baseline is a super fast machine. And in return you save some money, save some weight, get rid of the Touchbar, and get the wedge shape that doesn't put an edge right up against your wrists when typing on it the way a Pro does. Unless you really need every ounce of performance, there's a good chance an Air will just be a more enjoyable machine.

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#15

> this changes everything > As you can see, M1 Mac beats Intel Mac in every Lightroom benchmark across the board Yeah, by a relatively small amount according to your own charts... It's still impressive, not exactly earth shattering.

Running through emulation and on an entry level first generation machine that is significantly cheaper

This statement is vacuous unless you can quantify how much faster non-emulated software will be

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#16

> this changes everything > As you can see, M1 Mac beats Intel Mac in every Lightroom benchmark across the board Yeah, by a relatively small amount according to your own charts... It's still impressive, not exactly earth shattering.

I've mentioned this a few times but it does seem to be completely glossed over. Intel has for the most part been stuck on 6 year old 14nm and it's positively ancient compared to TSMC 5nm upon which the M1 is manufactured, it's to all intends and purposes two generations ahead. This is big card Apple got to play.

Intel have managed to squeeze an incredible amount of performance out of their 14nm (+++...) but it's at a cost and that cost was power consumption, they had no other choice with their DOA 10nm (hyperbole for affect :)).

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#17
post #3

Nothing really new in this post, not sure how this still makes the top of hn. Don't buy the pro, buy the air. The fan is a negative, not a positive, and the case is a lot more handy. Also, real buttons. I was one of the people who liked the touchbar, but I don't miss it at all

> The fan is a negative, not a positive

I will keep my cooling, thank you very much

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#18
Why would you buy this and not the Air? Same max RAM, same CPU, just slightly more battery. The Touch Bar is the only thing and I personally never found it that useful. I guess this has more ports too?

Or am I missing something? If this chip had more cores or was a variant with all 8 performance cores that would be a thing.

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#19

> this changes everything > As you can see, M1 Mac beats Intel Mac in every Lightroom benchmark across the board Yeah, by a relatively small amount according to your own charts... It's still impressive, not exactly earth shattering.

Running through emulation and on an entry level first generation machine that is significantly cheaper

The Rosetta 2 translation is very impressive.

The $2600 32GB 2TB Intel-based Macbook Pro 13" is only $300 more than the $2300 16GB 2TB M1-based Macbook Pro 13", though. If you could spec the M1 with 32GB, it would probably cost the same.

As pointed out, if you go with 1TB, you save $400. As per usual, the upgrade prices are (in my opinion) crazy!

Re: Apple Silicon M1 MacBook Pro Review: This Changes Everything

#20
post #14

I think a lot of people who have been reflexively buying new MacBook Pros every couple years should do themselves a favor and seriously consider a MacBook Air this time around. It's the same performance most of the time, and for tasks longer than 5 minutes, thermal throttling will only reduce performance by ~20% or so - for many that's still, plenty, plenty fast, when the baseline is a super fast machine. And in retu…

And, coming from the other side: recent years has seen the pro offer less and less in terms of ports and user-upgradability (two of the solid reasons to buy a pro in previous years).

Point being: the air and the pro seem be converging to a single point and the air is already there.

Post reply on HN