Live data from Hacker News

Let’s mug a startup founder

thinkvitamin.com

11–20 of 80 posts

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#11
post #4

From their FAQ ( http://oxygenaccelerator.com/accelerator/faqs/ ): When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis.

[deleted]

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't say anything about not having to pay it back if you don't reach profitability. Their answer to "Do I have to pay back the pre-seed funding?" is "Yes".

Did you stop reading right there? Here's the next line - > When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis. It makes it sound like the loan is to t…

It certainly _sounds_ that way, but the fine print is what matters. Is the loan a liability of the founder? or the company? Are these super-early ventures actually incorporated? Do they have the savvy to ask these questions? For the sums involved they certainly can't afford much legal advice.

And the structure isn't necessary to meet the stated goal of an "evergreen" fund, as equity returns on successful venture should fill that need.

It's an odd structure, at best.

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't say anything about not having to pay it back if you don't reach profitability. Their answer to "Do I have to pay back the pre-seed funding?" is "Yes".

Did you stop reading right there? Here's the next line - > When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis. It makes it sound like the loan is to t…

"Hey guys we're really just a bunch of cool, laid-back guys who are only interested in the success of your business. SRSLY"

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't say anything about not having to pay it back if you don't reach profitability. Their answer to "Do I have to pay back the pre-seed funding?" is "Yes".

Did you stop reading right there? Here's the next line - > When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis. It makes it sound like the loan is to t…

I'd be very interested to see what their rights to call the loan are. If they demanded to be paid out of the next round it could be disasterous.

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you stop reading right there? Here's the next line - > When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis. It makes it sound like the loan is to t…

It certainly _sounds_ that way, but the fine print is what matters. Is the loan a liability of the founder? or the company? Are these super-early ventures actually incorporated? Do they have the savvy to ask these questions? For the sums involved they certainly can't afford much legal advice. And the structure isn't necessary to meet the stated goal of an "evergreen" fund, as equity returns on successful venture shou…

I've seen loan-for-equity twice in real life, and both times it built profitable businesses. Though they were both older types of businesses with established business models that needed capital to get started, not technology.

Anyways, yes, you should always read the terms on an important contract very carefully, and here's no different. Probably a bad deal if there's a personal guarantee on the loan.

But assuming the contract is square, I could see circumstances that I'd take this deal in a heartbeat - starting a brand new company with 94% equity, $33k cash in the bank, and a $33k loan with very flexible repayment terms seems like it'd have a much higher chance of success than starting with 100% equity, $0 cash, and $0 debt.

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't say anything about not having to pay it back if you don't reach profitability. Their answer to "Do I have to pay back the pre-seed funding?" is "Yes".

Did you stop reading right there? Here's the next line - > When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis. It makes it sound like the loan is to t…

"Don't worry", coming from people who I'm going to owe money to, generally makes me worry.

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#18
post #4

From their FAQ ( http://oxygenaccelerator.com/accelerator/faqs/ ): When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis.

It's like saying: give me your house and don't worry, despite the property transfer, I'll allow you to continue to stay there for free; evictions will be done on a case-by-case basis.

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#19
post #4

From their FAQ ( http://oxygenaccelerator.com/accelerator/faqs/ ): When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis.

I read the FAQ and the phrase that immediately popped up in my head was "loan sharks":

- It wasn't at all clear from the website that the money would be a loan - I only got confirmation of this after several clicks to get to the FAQ.

- "Case-by-case" basis? Does that mean if they think someone is going to tank they'll ask for their money back? or perhaps they'll want it back before the next cycle?

- As another commenter has said, the phrase "don't worry" from money lenders makes me feel queasy.

I realise the above points are very touchy-feely but compared to what else is out there, I wouldn't be willing to even consider these guys.

Re: Let’s mug a startup founder

#20
post #4

From their FAQ ( http://oxygenaccelerator.com/accelerator/faqs/ ): When do I have to pay the pre-seed funding back? Don’t worry, we really don’t want you to hand over the keys to your house or car – this is a soft loan. Our interest is in your success and therefore will only look for the loan to be repaid when it makes sense for your business. This will be done on a case-by-case basis.

This sounds a bit suspicious to me, i.e. I couldn't help but reading this in a fake Brooklyn/Jersey accent wise guy accent.

How are such loans handled in the UK regarding liability? I mean, if you have a limited company, does one of the founders have to vouch for it with his personal possessions (as it's often handled here in Germany, for obvious reasons)?

Yes, if you're doing good, they won't be hasty in getting the money back, but they just might kick you on your way down, possibly thus ruining your last shot of getting back up again.

Post reply on HN