Live data from Hacker News

Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

github.com

11–20 of 636 posts

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#11
post #7

It lists file system case sensitivity as a pro, which it isn't. Case sensitivity is the default you get when you don't think about the users, and windows chose the opposite because it's better.

Ignoring the issue of which is better, windows isn't even uniform across the OS in its filesystem case-sensitivity. You can insert identical-other-than-case files with some kernel calls and break everything when you try to modify them later with the more common file interfaces.

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#12
post #9

Objective reasons to prefer anything else over Linux: Security. Linux is now the least secure desktop OS available, with limited sandboxing and no provision for checking binary signatures. It's 2020, the net is a dangerous place, and if you want to avoid malware, signature checks must be done on everything from the bootloader up through the user application code.

[deleted]

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#13
post #9

Objective reasons to prefer anything else over Linux: Security. Linux is now the least secure desktop OS available, with limited sandboxing and no provision for checking binary signatures. It's 2020, the net is a dangerous place, and if you want to avoid malware, signature checks must be done on everything from the bootloader up through the user application code.

> Linux is now the least secure desktop OS available

[citation needed]

> limited sandboxing

seccomp? Namespaces? What exactly do you want Linux to be able to sandbox that it can't?

> no provision for checking binary signatures

Bootloaders already enforce this for the kernel, and the kernel can enforce it for its own modules. Userlands are free to enforce it for userspace programs (e.g., how Android requires APKs to be signed).

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#14
post #9

Objective reasons to prefer anything else over Linux: Security. Linux is now the least secure desktop OS available, with limited sandboxing and no provision for checking binary signatures. It's 2020, the net is a dangerous place, and if you want to avoid malware, signature checks must be done on everything from the bootloader up through the user application code.

[deleted]

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#15
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As long as it's not ubuntu for the first two points

Saying Ubuntu has telemetry like Windows is shaky at best. Ubuntu asks you whether you want it, doesn't mandate it for people who don't buy enterprise licenses, and doesn't sneak in new kinds of telemetry when you already disabled what's there. Saying Ubuntu overrides auto-update settings is just false. If you turn off automatic updates, nothing will automatically update.

[deleted]

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#18
post #5

Does it have to be better, or even preferable? Is "it's sufficiently good for my needs but it's free" not enough? Whole industries have died because a free product has emerged that's "good enough" for 90+% of people. When was the last time anybody bought the electronic Encyclopedia Brittanica now we have Wikipedia?

Strangely I stumbled across an article today on the online Encyclopedia Brittanica which didn’t have an equivalent on Wikipedia. I wonder if anyone has ever done a comparison to find all the article on one but not the other.

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#19

Where is the corresponding document listing objective reasons to prefer Windows over Linux? Without that, this effort cannot be taken seriously.

Without a counterpoint providing an opposing view, how are we supposed to take your comment seriously?

Re: Reasons to prefer Linux over Windows (2014)

#20
I know quite a lot of folks here are fed up with moves away from native apps and towards Electron-wrapped web apps (and often for totally valid reasons) but it's been a godsend for making Linux a usable daily driver OS. IMO if you're doing eg web dev work in a GSuite / Slack / Figma / etc organization, it's never been a better time to try desktop Linux!
Post reply on HN