Live data from Hacker News

Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

bbc.com

11–20 of 84 posts

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#11
post #3

The infections are spiking but for example in Madrid the number of hospital beds with covid patients is holding steady at 19% (as of October 23). https://www.epdata.es/datos/evolucion-coronavirus-cada-comun... So many people are getting ill but a lot less are ending up in hospital than March-April. I find the discussion about number of cases to be a distraction.

[deleted]

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#12
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The pipeline is cases -> hospitalizations -> deaths, with a week or 2-weeks between each stage. Only 20% of cases turn into hospitalizations, and only a small percentage of hospitalizations turn into deaths... but that's the general pipeline. The exact % changes depending on population dynamics (who gets sick, and where), but the biggest contributing factor is the number of people in the previous stage of the pipelin…

Well I'm saying the Madrid numbers are not bearing out the prognosis you are outlining. It could be younger people are getting ill and that elderly people are better isolated but it's hard to know because they don't provide deaths by age groups.

My spanish isn't the best, but with assistance from Google Translate, I'm able to line up the death-charts with the cases charts.

https://imgur.com/cJw6dTk.png

If I'm reading that spanish correctly: its "Number of daily cases" (casos diarios) on the top, with "number of deaths" (Muertos) on the bottom, both in Madrid alone.

----------

The first wave is clearly wreaked by undertesting the population: Spain probably just didn't have enough tests to really count the cases back then. But for the 2nd wave (going until today), the death numbers clearly went up a few weeks after the case-count went up.

The case-count has begun to decline in Madrid, I think they're "over the hump" (knock on wood...). So looking forward, they're in a good spot.

But you can clearly see: when cases go up, deaths go up soon afterwards. When cases go down, the deaths go down soon afterwards.

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#13
post #3

The infections are spiking but for example in Madrid the number of hospital beds with covid patients is holding steady at 19% (as of October 23). https://www.epdata.es/datos/evolucion-coronavirus-cada-comun... So many people are getting ill but a lot less are ending up in hospital than March-April. I find the discussion about number of cases to be a distraction.

The pipeline is cases -> hospitalizations -> deaths, with a week or 2-weeks between each stage. Only 20% of cases turn into hospitalizations, and only a small percentage of hospitalizations turn into deaths... but that's the general pipeline. The exact % changes depending on population dynamics (who gets sick, and where), but the biggest contributing factor is the number of people in the previous stage of the pipelin…

!remindme 2 weeks

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#14
post #3

The infections are spiking but for example in Madrid the number of hospital beds with covid patients is holding steady at 19% (as of October 23). https://www.epdata.es/datos/evolucion-coronavirus-cada-comun... So many people are getting ill but a lot less are ending up in hospital than March-April. I find the discussion about number of cases to be a distraction.

The infections are spiking

Not in Madrid. From your own link, the number of new cases in Madrid has been holding steady around 2,500-3,500 for a month now [0]. Since the average hospital stay for Covid-19 is around 20 days, the in-flow and out-flow of patients in hospital beds should reach a steady state. In fact, you can see from [1] that the number of new cases was higher in september than in october, so we should expect to see a slight decline in hospital occupation over the first few weeks of october, which is exactly what the charts show [2].

So if you start your post with a falsehood, what value does the rest of your post have?

[0] https://www.epdata.es/casos-diarios-coronavirus-lugar-ultimo...

[1] https://www.epdata.es/evolucion-nuevos-casos-diarios-coronav...

[2] https://www.epdata.es/porcentaje-camas-hospital-ocupadas-pac...

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#15
post #4
post #3

The infections are spiking but for example in Madrid the number of hospital beds with covid patients is holding steady at 19% (as of October 23). https://www.epdata.es/datos/evolucion-coronavirus-cada-comun... So many people are getting ill but a lot less are ending up in hospital than March-April. I find the discussion about number of cases to be a distraction.

not sure why you're being downvoted. The situation right now is much better than it was during the first wave. ( https://imgur.com/nDgb7d7 , representative of most countries)

"much better" may be a matter of opinion but it's definitely getting worse.

There are 2500 patients in intensive care in France. Far from the 7000 at the peak but they were just 1000 one month ago and 1500 two weeks ago.

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#16
Belgian here, the covid situation is being handled very poorly. The rules change frequently and are badly communicated, the three main regions (Brussels, Flanders and Wallonia) all have different set of rules and information is contradicting.

E.g Flanders: Schools are not a problem vs Wallonia: Schools are a problem.

It's frustrating to see.

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#18
Trump gets most of the attention, but this whole pandemic has laid plain how liberal republics have been hollowed out by neoliberalism over the past few decades. The capability for broad, fast, collective action has been all-but wiped out, even in the supposedly enlightened and well-run countries of Western Europe. The nations that defeated fascism are crippled by a far weaker threat.

I can't think of another liberal democracy besides NZ that has handled COVID well, and they are a small island country. It's embarrassing, because the response has been terrible on both purely financial and humanitarian levels.

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#19

Belgian here, the covid situation is being handled very poorly. The rules change frequently and are badly communicated, the three main regions (Brussels, Flanders and Wallonia) all have different set of rules and information is contradicting. E.g Flanders: Schools are not a problem vs Wallonia: Schools are a problem. It's frustrating to see.

Well, good to know it is not just the US.

Re: Covid: Belgian doctors with coronavirus asked to keep working

#20

Belgian here, the covid situation is being handled very poorly. The rules change frequently and are badly communicated, the three main regions (Brussels, Flanders and Wallonia) all have different set of rules and information is contradicting. E.g Flanders: Schools are not a problem vs Wallonia: Schools are a problem. It's frustrating to see.

I agree the handling by our politicians seems incompetent, visionless, after the fact, ...

But I have the impression Belgium is not unique here. Most of the first world is doing bad.

I get the impression our political generation is systemically mismanaging for at least 20 years, and this crisis is the first of a level that makes it extremely obvious in all our countrys at the same time.

Post reply on HN