Live data from Hacker News

Is Stupidity Expanding? Some Hypotheses

greaterwrong.com

11–20 of 307 posts

Re: Is Stupidity Expanding? Some Hypotheses

#11
Maybe stupidity is just entertaining and gets promoted because of that?

As I watch another flat earth debunking video suggested by youtube to have a laugh I'm wondering ... Am I the part of the problem?

How popular stupidity would be without people pointing fingers at stupidity and laughing?

Re: Is Stupidity Expanding? Some Hypotheses

#13

Almost every one of the possible explanations (for rising stupidity, and for rising perception of stupidity if it isn't real), looked plausible to me. But that probably just means that "stupid" isn't a word with a precise enough definition, and so for each of the possible ways to define it, one (or more) of the various answers applies. But, in general, it seems not unrelated to the phenomenon in which weird things ar…

It's also often presented as if it is representative. See the various people-on-the-street 'interviews' of people with opposing viewpoints being argued with by the interviewer who clearly came armed for an ambush.

Re: Is Stupidity Expanding? Some Hypotheses

#16
The Reserve Banks of the world are making people dumber by aiming for full employment... This means stimulating the economy and giving companies an incentive to create jobs which don't need to exist... Because the jobs are useless, people start to focus on increasingly menial and tedious tasks and lose their sense of pragmatism. We've all seen meetings going around in circles for hours, people arguing about tedium, coming up with bureaucratic procedures, adopting bureaucratic workflows, etc...

Most people have a deeply held trust in authority and so they tend to think the problem lies within themselves rather than something wrong in their environment and so they dumb themselves down in order to normalize their situation...

In order to cope with their environment, they convince themselves that what they're doing is useful and, in doing so, they start to neglect their own common sense and they gradually lose it.

Re: Is Stupidity Expanding? Some Hypotheses

#19
People have gotten stupider because the world is too complex (and fundamentally impossible) to understand in a completely rational way. Historically we have relied upon intuition, heuristics, and a network of trusted authority figures (usually a network of trusted institutions).

The modern condition (post Enlightenment) can be understood as the elevation of rationality over all else and hostility towards heuristics and intuition. Heuristics and intuition come from listening to your grandmother and from sources like the Bible and old folktales.

Furthermore the networks of trust and the institutions are completely and utterly corrupt, inhabited and headed by the worst (morally speaking) and dumbest people (intellectually speaking) in society. Think Harvard and The New York Times.

The typical modern person (including the vast majority of people on HN) are almost completely hopeless when it comes to what we would traditionally define as "not being stupid" (aka "not being a sucker").

In your own life if you think of the stupidest people you know they tend to be the most "intelligent" (software engineers, PHDs, doctors, lawyers, etc). That's modernity.

Re: Is Stupidity Expanding? Some Hypotheses

#20
I suspect 3 and 10 - the internet is more accessible to the masses and rather than becoming smarter when information was more available they mept their same patterns and they communicate more over it which makes it easier to notice when they were confined to say doing stupid stunts or staging innane protests for stupid causes. Remember when Jackass and Reality TV were considered the downfall of civilization? (Although there some may half-seriously blame Trump on the latter it is a matter of debate of how much he is considered a symptom vs a problem in himself.)
Post reply on HN