Live data from Hacker News

Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

cloudflarestatus.com

11–20 of 25 posts

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#11
post #2

Brilliant idea to recentralize the decentralized internet. Edit: With more information coming in, I don't think the current issue is specific to Cloudflare. FWIW I'm having zero issues in mid-US.

What is better: If only I go down and my competitors are still up, or if everybody goes down? ;)

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#12
post #2

Brilliant idea to recentralize the decentralized internet. Edit: With more information coming in, I don't think the current issue is specific to Cloudflare. FWIW I'm having zero issues in mid-US.

What is better: If only I go down and my competitors are still up, or if everybody goes down? ;)

If your competitors go down and you re still up.

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#13
post #6
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Aren't their services decentralized?

I think the parent means centralizing in one single company

But if the issue is with transit (as it appears to be) and Cloudflare peer with multiple transit providers - how is it worse? Of course in other circumstances a single dominant player may be an issue - but it doesn’t look to be the issue here - and if anything their level of peering would allow faster recovery than other smaller content hosts (used in the loosest sense) which may have less peering.

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#14
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the parent means centralizing in one single company

But if the issue is with transit (as it appears to be) and Cloudflare peer with multiple transit providers - how is it worse? Of course in other circumstances a single dominant player may be an issue - but it doesn’t look to be the issue here - and if anything their level of peering would allow faster recovery than other smaller content hosts (used in the loosest sense) which may have less peering.

But seemingly contrarian views get upvotes.

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#15
post #7
post #2

Brilliant idea to recentralize the decentralized internet. Edit: With more information coming in, I don't think the current issue is specific to Cloudflare. FWIW I'm having zero issues in mid-US.

Well, for most smaller websites using something like Cloudflare means they are more decentralized, more easily, than less (e.g. instead of using their single source of failure own server).

1000000 smaller websites on CloudFlare sounds like a whole lot more centralised than 1000 smaller independent solutions.

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#16
This isn't a Cloudflare-specific issue. Level 3/CenturyLink are in trouble. Affecting other providers (see, for example, Fastly's Status page: https://status.fastly.com/).

@dang or another mod, would be better to link to https://puck.nether.net/pipermail/outages/2020-August/013187... as this isn't a Cloudflare issue.

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#17
post #7
post #2

Brilliant idea to recentralize the decentralized internet. Edit: With more information coming in, I don't think the current issue is specific to Cloudflare. FWIW I'm having zero issues in mid-US.

Well, for most smaller websites using something like Cloudflare means they are more decentralized, more easily, than less (e.g. instead of using their single source of failure own server).

I don't really know why we need to discuss this now but the point has nothing to do with this.

Small sites don't really need that decentralization, sure it's nice that it's easy but this isn't the problem.

The problem is that in aggregate you end up with an internet with a single point of failure.

And even if as it is now isn't a big problem, who's to say that one day it is a huge problem?

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mandatory comment on Cloudflare discussions, right?

shouldnt it be?

It’s a point, but it’s repeated ad nauseum in every thread. It’s the nature of having CDNs or cloud services in the first place. If you want to outsource your uptime, you sacrifice certain freedoms you had in exchange for hypothetically lower costs for operations.

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#19

This isn't a Cloudflare-specific issue. Level 3/CenturyLink are in trouble. Affecting other providers (see, for example, Fastly's Status page: https://status.fastly.com/ ). @dang or another mod, would be better to link to https://puck.nether.net/pipermail/outages/2020-August/013187... as this isn't a Cloudflare issue.

The Level3 outage thread is here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24322861

Re: Cloudflare is experiencing failures in its connections to hosts

#20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

shouldnt it be?

It’s a point, but it’s repeated ad nauseum in every thread. It’s the nature of having CDNs or cloud services in the first place. If you want to outsource your uptime, you sacrifice certain freedoms you had in exchange for hypothetically lower costs for operations.

a lot of people feel that the outsourcing was unnecessary for a lot of low-traffic sites, and was mainly the result of marketing pushing cloudflare to everyone. It doesn't make sense that some tiny blogs go down when there's a cloudflare outage. And it creates side effects too: e.g. cloudflare's anti-spam checks make it nearly impossible to create a functioning link fetcher/previewer unless you re a big enough site to ask for a manual exception.
Post reply on HN