Live data from Hacker News

A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

thingspondered.xyz

11–20 of 28 posts

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#11
I’ve heard this joke in another guise:

An engineer, a physicist, and a mathematician are sitting in a train compartment and travelling through some countryside. Presently they come upon a field, which contains a white sheep.

“Oh look, in this country sheep are white!”, exclaims the engineer. “Oh, how unwarranted!”, exclaims the physicist “in this country, there exists a white sheep, on a specific field.” The mathematician just tut-tuts and curses under his breath. “In this country there exists at least one field, wherein there exists at least one sheep, at least one side of which is white.”

Oh, and another great one I enjoy:

An engineer, a physicist, and a mathematician sign up for a psychology experiment. They are each locked in a room with a tin of baked beans, the idea being that they will have to figure out how to open the tin with no tools in order not to starve.

Sometime later, the experimenters check up on them.

First, they come to the engineer’s cell. There’s a contented engineer sitting in the corner, craters on the wall, and the shrapnel of a totally shredded can strewn around. They ask him what he did. “Oh, I just battered it up against the wall.” Fair enough, they think.

Next, they check in on the physicist. They find him somewhat dishevelled, the walls covered with scratched calculations, and a neatly severed can in the middle of the room. They ask him for his account. “Oh, I calculated that if I emitted a note on a certain pitch, resonance would eventually cleave the can in half. It took me some time to figure out the note, though.” Again, fair enough.

Finally they get to the mathematician, whom they find shrivelled up, sitting cross-legged on the floor in front of an intact can as if venerating it, muttering “assume the can is open, assume the can is open”.

:)

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#12
post #6
post #5

Seems there are many variations on this joke. The one I know: An astronomer, a physicist and a mathematician go for a walk in the countryside. They spy a black sheep in the distance. The astronomer immediately proclaims, "All sheep are black!" The physicist thinks for a moment and suggests, "Some sheep are black." The mathematician ponders awhile and says, "There exists a sheep such that at minimum one of its sides i…

There is the joke where scientists lock an engineer, a physicist, and a mathematician each in a room with a bed and a can of soup. In the morning they open the rooms one by one. In the first room the engineer is asleep and there is mangled open can of soup on the floor. They wake him up and ask about the soup can. And he says, I got hungry so I smashed the soup can against floor to open it. Next room the physicist wa…

The joke is usually an economist saying, "assume a can opener": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assume_a_can_opener

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#13
For a physicist, taking a mixed solution isn't "game theoretic", it's an "ensemble average" solution.

(... and, thinking of time-averaging, you all have forgotten "on at least one side, at least once during their lifetime." If programming has taught me anything, it's that variables won't yet constants aren't.)

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#15

I remember a similar joke from a book some years ago from the school: An engineer, a physicist and a mathematician are on a train crossing an unknown country. Suddenly, the engineer leaning out of the window says: "in this country the sheep are black!"; the physicist corrects: "in this region of the country, some sheep are black"; the mathematician limits himself saying: "at least from one of their sides."

This joke is even listed as an example of a maths joke on wikipedia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_joke#Stereotype...

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#17
A mathematician, a physicist, and an engineer are asked to determine the volume of a red ball.

The mathematician takes calipers to determine the diameter and uses the formula for area of a sphere.

The physicist fills a bucket completely, places it in a larger bucket, submerges the ball and then measures the volume of the water that spilled.

The engineer reads the part number off the bottom of the ball, and then copies the volume from the data sheet.

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#18

> A physicist and a mathematician are flying cross-country together. Each is keeping a diary of the trip. They fly over a white horse in Iowa. The physicist writes, 'There is a white horse in Iowa.' The mathematician writes, 'There exists, somewhere in the Midwest, a horse, white on top. Reminds me of a quote from a favorite textbook [1] of mine: > In mathematics, an argument must be airtight; that is, convincing in…

The Coq community is here to say that that claim is not true for most of math. Much false or weakly argued math is published and accepted. Mathematics is done only to the level of "reasonable doubt"

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#19
post #16

Physics is mathematics with the constraint of reality. Engineering is physics with the constraint of money.

Yeah, according to Vladimir Arnold physics and mathematics is in fact the same science.

All science is the same science.

Re: A joke about the difference between mathematicians and physicists

#20
post #3

This is a bit related: xkcd: Certainty [1] Edit: Here’s the text transcript: > [A door seen from a hallway, with "Teachers' Lounge" on the glass, next to the door is a sign reading "Award." Inside the door are two teachers talking.] > Megan: My students drew me into another political argument. > Cueball: Eh; it happens. > Megan: Lately, political debates bother me. They just show how good smart people are at rational…

Truths in which universe?
Post reply on HN