Don't understand why they don't just use an inflatable parachute with a radio beacon antenna sticking out the top. Then they could just drive up anytime and fish it out of the water. Would immersion in salt water for a few hours damage a fairing?
Yes. The couple they reused after fishing them out required extensive rebuilds.
There are a lot of electronics on these things and weight is ultimate factor.
This website is not trustworthy and doesn't respect GDPR as it redirects to https://guce.advertising.com/collectIdentifiers?sessionId Engadget, stop this nonsense and change the responsibilities of the team who decided to put this into production.
While I fully agree with this sentiment generally, I wonder what people think of NPR and WaPo in comparison (both give much less choice than Engadget).
I seem to see this complaint on every Verizon-property article posted, but NPR and WaPo get excused?
Don't understand why they don't just use an inflatable parachute with a radio beacon antenna sticking out the top. Then they could just drive up anytime and fish it out of the water. Would immersion in salt water for a few hours damage a fairing?
Or grab them with a hook dangling from a C-130 like the film from old-timey spy satellites.
Apparently thats been considered, and you still might see another company like electron try it. It's just a bit harder to do safely and some other limitations.
Don't understand why they don't just use an inflatable parachute with a radio beacon antenna sticking out the top. Then they could just drive up anytime and fish it out of the water. Would immersion in salt water for a few hours damage a fairing?
Salt water is the worst. It takes a lot of effort to clean it all off and it causes corrosion all the while. Even the ones that do hit water, they get them out as fast as they safely can.
As far as I know (correct me if I'm wrong), SpaceX have only reused previously-wet farings on their own Starlink launches. They don't risk potentially damaged parts on external customers.
Don't understand why they don't just use an inflatable parachute with a radio beacon antenna sticking out the top. Then they could just drive up anytime and fish it out of the water. Would immersion in salt water for a few hours damage a fairing?
Forget immersion- just contacting salt water is enough to wreck your day. It's highly corrosive and protecting from that corrosion would require engineering coatings that are light, cheap, and also able to handle the temperature and pressure and wind stresses of a literal rocket launch. It's a lot.
there were a couple guys using acrobatic parachutes and some control code to fly high power model rockets back to the pad saving an hour walk. I wonder if SpaceX could use the same technique and fly the fairings to the ships.
This website is not trustworthy and doesn't respect GDPR as it redirects to https://guce.advertising.com/collectIdentifiers?sessionId Engadget, stop this nonsense and change the responsibilities of the team who decided to put this into production.
While I fully agree with this sentiment generally, I wonder what people think of NPR and WaPo in comparison (both give much less choice than Engadget). I seem to see this complaint on every Verizon-property article posted, but NPR and WaPo get excused? I wonder is it just a UX difference?
European here, the NPR plain text site is a joy to use and I consider it one of the best and most compliant solutions, If I accidentally click a WaPo link I just navigate away from the paywall. Same with TechCrunch.
there were a couple guys using acrobatic parachutes and some control code to fly high power model rockets back to the pad saving an hour walk. I wonder if SpaceX could use the same technique and fly the fairings to the ships.
That's what they already do. It's a steerable parafoil. How would they be expected to get the ship lined up underneath the parafoil in time to catch it otherwise?
Don't understand why they don't just use an inflatable parachute with a radio beacon antenna sticking out the top. Then they could just drive up anytime and fish it out of the water. Would immersion in salt water for a few hours damage a fairing?
Or grab them with a hook dangling from a C-130 like the film from old-timey spy satellites.
They considered doing that to reuse the Saturn V with a giant helicopter with rockets at the end of each propeller. It didnt go anywhere. Though people have been using air capture for more reasonable use cases, and rocket lab is going to be air capturing their electron rockets.
Don't understand why they don't just use an inflatable parachute with a radio beacon antenna sticking out the top. Then they could just drive up anytime and fish it out of the water. Would immersion in salt water for a few hours damage a fairing?
Or grab them with a hook dangling from a C-130 like the film from old-timey spy satellites.
The problem with this and a fairing is that if the fairing catches the open side, it's going to drag behind like a giant parachute and take the plane down. The fairing is huge (13m long x 5m diameter), even compared to a big plane.