Live data from Hacker News

German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

9to5mac.com

11–20 of 36 posts

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#11

I wonder just how fun a corporate, locked-down, Mac will be.

About as fun as a corporate, locked-down PC is.

That's what I'm afraid of. I was hoping people would be less likely to completely hose a Mac and therefore there would be a lower need for draconian restrictions.

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#12
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

mac dominates the design/music/film industries though

Any evidence to back this up? I'm a web designer, I know a ton of other designers and they are all either multi-OS capable or fall firstly into the PC camp. The posers (fresh out of school, concerned about image/style still) usually are using Macs. /ducks

shrug

Every design team I've worked with, startup or Fortune 500, has been on Macs. Yes, that's just more anecdotal "evidence" but I've been a consultant in several companies over the last ten years.

One Fortune 100 company I worked at had slowly moved the entire web development team (front end and back end) onto Macs. The front end guys liked Photoshop on the Mac, and the OS level colorsync support, and the higher gamut LCDs (versus your run of the mill Dells - no one was springing for the $5k+ displays). The back end guys liked that they could run the same bash scripts and ant execs on their local machines as would be running on the Solaris production servers. Having a 99% compatible bash shell available out of the box, and having the same path separators makes a big difference.

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#13
post #6

More interesting is this "Until now the highest profile switcher has been Auto Warehouse Co. which is in the midst of a switch of 1000 desktops" That's it?!? And they're not even done, which means the largest installation is now under 1K. Shows how far the Mac platform has to go in the 9-5 world.

mac dominates the design/music/film industries though

Contrary to popular belief, actually Linux dominates the film industry.

http://www.desktoplinux.com/articles/AT5611327583.html

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

About as fun as a corporate, locked-down PC is.

That's what I'm afraid of. I was hoping people would be less likely to completely hose a Mac and therefore there would be a lower need for draconian restrictions.

Operating systems are not 'fun', it's like saying my house is 'fun'. It's what you do on or in the OS that makes it fun.

I've experienced this over the years with Linux. I will from time to time install the latest greatest distro, configure it, work out all the little nagging bugs and then ....

Nothing, it's not fun (unless you think getting your graphics card to work and spending 4 hours doing it is fun), in fact the goal is always to get the OS to the point where I can use it ... for something else.

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#15
post #7

You know, back in the day, it was normal for everyone to have two computers on their desktop. There would be a generic PC running Windows with a 14" monitor for word processing and email, and there would be another machine for "actual work". If you were an engineer, it might be a SPARC or RS/6000 workstation. If you were a designer, probably a Mac or an SGI. Nowadays you can get one box to do everything, a Mac is a U…

Can someone explain to me why designers should use Mac? I can't see any significant differences between Photoshop and Illustrator run in Windows and Mac.

Shhhh, there isn't. But don't bring that up because it's very cool to use a Mac, it makes you so creative and cutting edge. Rainbows and unicorns and dogs shitting ice cream and all that.

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#16
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

mac dominates the design/music/film industries though

Contrary to popular belief, actually Linux dominates the film industry. http://www.desktoplinux.com/articles/AT5611327583.html

Shocking, real evidence that doesn't back up the widely accepted 'truth' that Macs are for the 'creative people'.

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#17
post #7

You know, back in the day, it was normal for everyone to have two computers on their desktop. There would be a generic PC running Windows with a 14" monitor for word processing and email, and there would be another machine for "actual work". If you were an engineer, it might be a SPARC or RS/6000 workstation. If you were a designer, probably a Mac or an SGI. Nowadays you can get one box to do everything, a Mac is a U…

Can someone explain to me why designers should use Mac? I can't see any significant differences between Photoshop and Illustrator run in Windows and Mac.

What's the name of your guide dog?

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#19
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any evidence to back this up? I'm a web designer, I know a ton of other designers and they are all either multi-OS capable or fall firstly into the PC camp. The posers (fresh out of school, concerned about image/style still) usually are using Macs. /ducks

shrug Every design team I've worked with, startup or Fortune 500, has been on Macs. Yes, that's just more anecdotal "evidence" but I've been a consultant in several companies over the last ten years. One Fortune 100 company I worked at had slowly moved the entire web development team (front end and back end) onto Macs. The front end guys liked Photoshop on the Mac, and the OS level colorsync support, and the higher g…

The front end guys 'liked Photoshp on the Mac'? And this was justification to move the entire department over? Uhhhhh, I'm sorry but if I were there and were supervising this department I'd need something more tangible than that to justify spending the company's money.

Re: German company switching 12,000 desktops from PC to Mac

#20
post #7

You know, back in the day, it was normal for everyone to have two computers on their desktop. There would be a generic PC running Windows with a 14" monitor for word processing and email, and there would be another machine for "actual work". If you were an engineer, it might be a SPARC or RS/6000 workstation. If you were a designer, probably a Mac or an SGI. Nowadays you can get one box to do everything, a Mac is a U…

Can someone explain to me why designers should use Mac? I can't see any significant differences between Photoshop and Illustrator run in Windows and Mac.

There used to be a difference and Adobe and Apple were very good friends many moons ago. Some people can't help but cling to a past where Windows was still only glare on Bill Gates's glasses. (I probably have my history wrong, but you get what I mean)
Post reply on HN