Live data from Hacker News

Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

nationalgeographic.com

11–20 of 136 posts

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#12
There was a similar thread for Germany here recently, and I remember someone saying that most companies will just start using multi-use plastics instead of single-use ones... without reusing them. Is that really likely or am I not foolish to hope that companies will eventually just research and use more biodegradable materials?

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#13
post #5

A significant inquiry I have to this in general is what should we do for people for which single-use plastics are exceptionally necessary for their lives? For example, people with disabilities who cannot manage paper straws (due to their collapsing before a drink can be consumed) or metal straws (due to mental strain in keeping track of their cleaning)?

Have you ever used a paper straw? It takes ages for it to dissolve so for most people, event the disabled ones, it is not a problem.

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#14
post #5

A significant inquiry I have to this in general is what should we do for people for which single-use plastics are exceptionally necessary for their lives? For example, people with disabilities who cannot manage paper straws (due to their collapsing before a drink can be consumed) or metal straws (due to mental strain in keeping track of their cleaning)?

Have you ever used a paper straw? It takes ages for it to dissolve so for most people, event the disabled ones, it is not a problem.

I personally don't have a problem but I know people who take a very long time to drink stuff.

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#15
post #7
post #2

Can we add cigarette filters to the list? If I had a penny for every ...

Ban single use paper and cotton? If you collected each you might have a penny a piece if you could recycle into something people want like homemade face masks.

It's not cotton, it's Cellulose Acetate. Not very bio-degradable usually

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#16
Interesting side-note: here in Vancouver BC, we were full steam ahead on eliminating plastics (e.g. styrofoam take-out containers, plastic drinking straws, shopping bags, etc.) but that was seemingly all instantly reversed once social distancing started.

I can understand the reversal of charging for shopping bags to encourage bringing reusable bags: reusable bags are potentially a disease vector.

But what's with the reintroduction of plastic straws over paper, and the reintroduction of styrofoam over paper boxes? A temporary cost-reduction measure, allowing the using-up of old stock these businesses had laying around?

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#17
post #5

A significant inquiry I have to this in general is what should we do for people for which single-use plastics are exceptionally necessary for their lives? For example, people with disabilities who cannot manage paper straws (due to their collapsing before a drink can be consumed) or metal straws (due to mental strain in keeping track of their cleaning)?

Have you ever used a paper straw? It takes ages for it to dissolve so for most people, event the disabled ones, it is not a problem.

No, they suck. They get soggy after a few minutes. I’d rather not use a straw at all.

Which brings me to my main point. The “paper straws” movement isn’t actually anti-climate-change or pro-ecology, but just virtue signalling. If it was real, they wouldn’t be advocating paper straws, they’d be advocating no straws at all! Hint: you don’t need a straw (the vast majority of people anyways).

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#18

Aren't there many legitimate uses of single-use plastics? Like medical products? What will Canada replace them with?

It's a law banning the use of single-use plastic for (a large number of) specific use-cases where it's unnecessary; not a law banning single-use plastics generally.

Re: Canada aims to ban single-use plastics by 2021

#19

Aren't there many legitimate uses of single-use plastics? Like medical products? What will Canada replace them with?

When this single-use plastics ban was in the news a year ago, there was a ton of exceptions to it.

It seems like in practice this will basically amount to a ban on plastic straws and grocery bags.

Post reply on HN