Live data from Hacker News

Controversies and Challenges in fMRI (2018)

thebrainblog.org

11–12 of 12 posts

Re: Controversies and Challenges in fMRI (2018)

#11
post #6

Of course, this is looking at the brain's power management system and trying to infer from that what processing is going on. If you did that for a CPU, you could see the FPU or the I/O controllers heating up, get a sense of how many cache misses were going on, and see how many CPU cores were doing anything. You could probably tell a game, spreadsheet, or web browser apart. This would not lead to much insight.

It would probably lead to more insight than not looking at which parts heat up. State of the art before fMRI was looking at people with very specific brain injuries, or using EEGs, which offer even lower fidelity.

Re: Controversies and Challenges in fMRI (2018)

#12
post #6

Of course, this is looking at the brain's power management system and trying to infer from that what processing is going on. If you did that for a CPU, you could see the FPU or the I/O controllers heating up, get a sense of how many cache misses were going on, and see how many CPU cores were doing anything. You could probably tell a game, spreadsheet, or web browser apart. This would not lead to much insight.

Except this is more like studying same where you don't actually know what a cpu is let alone cache miss. It's more like a caveman looking at pictures on the screen and noting that a certain area lights up when there is more red on the screen.
Post reply on HN