Live data from Hacker News

Music Theory for Beginners

whitakerblackall.com

11–20 of 110 posts

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#11
post #6

This is great. Can anyone recommend a "DAW (Digital Audio Workstation)" for Windows? Preferably with at least a free trial version. Thanks.

Reaper: http://reaper.fm/ is excellent, very cheap ($40) and has an unlimited trial. Unlimited both in time and scope, you get the full software. I use it, works great.

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#12

I teach Music Theory (and piano) for a living-- this is an excellent introduction to the most practical concepts. I was somewhat disappointed that the OP showed us a C Major scale without really explaining what a "major scale" is-- a collection of whole and half steps-- especially since they used a keyboard as an example, which is laid out in exactly the right pattern for teaching the major scale. (Notice that the bl…

Something to note: whole and half steps are not the only available type of steps, you can also move quarter steps. It's not common in Western music (if present at all) but very common in Middle Eastern music. Maqam world (http://maqamworld.com) provides a decent index of many Middle Eastern scales, some of them utilizing quarter tones.

For instance:

http://www.maqamworld.com/maqamat/rast.html

http://www.maqamworld.com/maqamat/bayati.html

http://www.maqamworld.com/maqamat/sikah.html

For those interested, each scale is accompanies by several audio samples to hear what it sounds like.

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#13

I teach Music Theory (and piano) for a living-- this is an excellent introduction to the most practical concepts. I was somewhat disappointed that the OP showed us a C Major scale without really explaining what a "major scale" is-- a collection of whole and half steps-- especially since they used a keyboard as an example, which is laid out in exactly the right pattern for teaching the major scale. (Notice that the bl…

I agree with you re: whole-steps and half-steps. When you teach "what makes a scale major?" in reference to the scales whole and half step pattern, it is then much easier to introduce minor, and scale modes (Ionian, Dorian, Phrygian). Basic theory taught in this way is really not that hard (however, I majored in music in school). If you introduce intervals, then you don't have to say "forget about B diminished. You won't miss it". You can say "B-dimished triad has a darker, more moody sound because it is made up of two-minor thirds. Or a Phrygian mode has an "eastern" sound because its scale starts with a half step.

That said, a lot of work went into the tutorial, and it is certainly well done.

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#15
post #2

A friend of mine here in Tokyo owns a small music company and recently launched a series of games to help with music training. They are flash-based, but I have been quite impressed with them and have enjoyed them quite a bit! He is using a freemium model, and you can try out the games on his website without even registering. (Free registration gives you progress tracking, and subscription gives you access to all leve…

Really good stuff! Bug report: after I created an account, I was given a "Registration successful. You are now logged in." flash message in the middle of a "Cookies Required" page. It seems to have logged me in correctly, though. http://i.imgur.com/KMBPQ.png

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#16
on a similar note (and because there's some great links being posted here), this video by walter lewin covers the physics of sound and how it relates to music, it could be good secondary material for someone learning about music theory:

http://mitworld.mit.edu/video/168

what's great is that it's a serious physics lecture, but designed for kids, and there's plenty of funky experiments within the one hour.

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#17
post #12

I teach Music Theory (and piano) for a living-- this is an excellent introduction to the most practical concepts. I was somewhat disappointed that the OP showed us a C Major scale without really explaining what a "major scale" is-- a collection of whole and half steps-- especially since they used a keyboard as an example, which is laid out in exactly the right pattern for teaching the major scale. (Notice that the bl…

Something to note: whole and half steps are not the only available type of steps, you can also move quarter steps. It's not common in Western music (if present at all) but very common in Middle Eastern music. Maqam world ( http://maqamworld.com ) provides a decent index of many Middle Eastern scales, some of them utilizing quarter tones. For instance: http://www.maqamworld.com/maqamat/rast.html http://www.maqamworld.…

There are many ways do divide an octave.

Steve Vai created a scale called the Xavian scale wich is dividing the octave by 10.

He used in on Deep Down Into The Pain

http://www.guitarflame.com/2008/xavian-scale-steve-vais-own-...

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#18
post #2

A friend of mine here in Tokyo owns a small music company and recently launched a series of games to help with music training. They are flash-based, but I have been quite impressed with them and have enjoyed them quite a bit! He is using a freemium model, and you can try out the games on his website without even registering. (Free registration gives you progress tracking, and subscription gives you access to all leve…

Three things

1. Send him this presentation: http://fury.com/2010/02/jesse-shells-mindblowing-talk-on-the...

2. Tell him to do it for the iphone and ipad where people can also practice on the ipad.

3. Set up achievement levels

Khan Academy for music education.

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#19

on a similar note (and because there's some great links being posted here), this video by walter lewin covers the physics of sound and how it relates to music, it could be good secondary material for someone learning about music theory: http://mitworld.mit.edu/video/168 what's great is that it's a serious physics lecture, but designed for kids, and there's plenty of funky experiments within the one hour.

If you want to go beyond the basics, I found this book invaluable:

http://www.maths.abdn.ac.uk/~bensondj/html/maths-music.html

Re: Music Theory for Beginners

#20
I hope the author turns this into a series, introducing additional theory. When I was first learning basic music theory, it was either all text or text along with notation. I took lesson on snare drum when I was younger, so I can read rhythms fine but never bothered to learn to read the pitches correctly. When I started playing guitar and piano, having something with embedded content and "piano roll" images would have helped immensely.
Post reply on HN