Live data from Hacker News

Video: Well-Designed Buildings Sway, But Stay Standing in Japan Quake

good.is

11–14 of 14 posts

Re: Video: Well-Designed Buildings Sway, But Stay Standing in Japan Quake

#11

Isn't it generally expected that skyscrapers will be pretty well-engineered? Are there any examples of skyscrapers being significantly damaged by an earthquake?

Yes, but 8.0+ quakes near major cities are rare enough that there's limited experience to draw from.

There hasn't been anything over 7.3 affecting the lower-48 United States in over a hundred years; nothing over 7.9 in over 300 years. (There was a ~9 in the pacific northwest in 1700.)

Japan's building standards are said to be the best in the world. An 8.0+ near a US city could include some nasty surprises for buildings of all types.

Re: Video: Well-Designed Buildings Sway, But Stay Standing in Japan Quake

#12

Isn't it generally expected that skyscrapers will be pretty well-engineered? Are there any examples of skyscrapers being significantly damaged by an earthquake?

That comment is just begging for the C. K. Louis routine to be cited. ;)

Re: Video: Well-Designed Buildings Sway, But Stay Standing in Japan Quake

#13

Damn.

Sorry, that was just my tounge-tied way of expressing admiration for the tremendous skill of Japanese civil engineers. Surely those building were designed without expecting them to survive an 8.9 earthquake, yet survive they did. I am in awe.

Re: Video: Well-Designed Buildings Sway, But Stay Standing in Japan Quake

#14

Isn't it generally expected that skyscrapers will be pretty well-engineered? Are there any examples of skyscrapers being significantly damaged by an earthquake?

That comment is just begging for the C. K. Louis routine to be cited. ;)

It's Louis C.K. His last name is Szekely. I'm not sure where the C.K. comes from.
Post reply on HN