Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

NASA Scientist Claims Evidence of Alien Life on Meteorite

foxnews.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 21 posts

Re: NASA Scientist Claims Evidence of Alien Life on Meteorite

#11

Post by extension »

pmorici wrote: post #10
extension wrote: post #9

Fox neglects to mention that their photo is an actual Titanospirillum bacterium, not the fossil found in the meteorite.

They have a track record of showing images and video with their reporting and imply the images are related to the news being discussed when they are often not.

They actually took the image from the paper, but they used the comparison image instead of the actual one.

Re: NASA Scientist Claims Evidence of Alien Life on Meteorite

#12

Post by rilindo »

jerf wrote: post #8
andrewheins wrote: post #3

Does anyone else question his choice to give FOXNews the exclusive? If you had made one of the most important scientific discoveries in history, would you submit it to FOX?

Unfortunately, it fits right in with history. NASA no longer has any credibility on the extraterrestrial life front. I've lost count of all their announcements, which have without fail turned out to be anything from arguably-fraudulent (though not quite provably so) up through so dubious it means nothing, like the previous meteorite results. They have a pretty picture in the news story, certainly, but I will wait for…

To be fair, this just a scientist who works for NASA who filed the paper, not NASA itself.

Re: NASA Scientist Claims Evidence of Alien Life on Meteorite

#13

Post by jarin »

jerf wrote: post #8
andrewheins wrote: post #3

Does anyone else question his choice to give FOXNews the exclusive? If you had made one of the most important scientific discoveries in history, would you submit it to FOX?

Unfortunately, it fits right in with history. NASA no longer has any credibility on the extraterrestrial life front. I've lost count of all their announcements, which have without fail turned out to be anything from arguably-fraudulent (though not quite provably so) up through so dubious it means nothing, like the previous meteorite results. They have a pretty picture in the news story, certainly, but I will wait for…

The announcement of "arsenic-based life" was particularly bad, as it turned out to just be normal life that can survive in a higher than normal concentration of arsenic.

Re: NASA Scientist Claims Evidence of Alien Life on Meteorite

#17

Post by StrawberryFrog »

jcfrei wrote: post #2

If the meteorites were found on earth, couldn't the fossils stem from local bacteria? Maybe the meteorite hit earth a long time ago, long enough so fossils could form.

The paper talks about that in length, and why he thinks that's not what happened. Obvious question is obvious.

Re: NASA Scientist Claims Evidence of Alien Life on Meteorite

#19

Post by hoag »

asmithmd1 wrote: post #7

Here is a link to the actual paper: http://journalofcosmology.com/Life100.html The Journal of Cosmology website looks a little sketchy to me -- not what I would expect from a serious science publication. Even if he could conclusively prove that he is seeing a fossil in a meteorite you couldn't discount the idea that these meteorites were blasted off the earth's surface and into space by some ancient, huge asteroid st…

I suppose the source meteorite could have been ejected matter from an impact with another planet that harbored life; i.e., a sort of "meteor vector." That, to me, seems far more plausible than life developing out of nothing on a meteor or comet in space.
Post reply on HN