Live data from Hacker News

The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

bloomberg.com

11–20 of 62 posts

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#11
post #8

I don't get it. It is estimated that below 50$/barrel Saudi Arabia is basically pushing wealth out of their country. (Balance of payment in negative, it is right?.) And below 80$/barrel they are running the country at a deficit. They are now selling to 30$/barrel. What is the strategy here? Push all "high-tech" producers out of the market and shut up the price again? How long can they last? And how much it will cost?

It's a stupid move, because the tech and reserves won't go away. As soon as prices rise again to levels needed by Saudi Arabia the reserves will be exploited again. Probably they hope that banks give less money and hedges to shale companies, but that won't work long-term.

Saudi Arabia may see civil unrest soon as the house of Saud need all the money they can to spend on social welfare to stay in power.

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#12

Saudi Arabia has shifted away from thinking like manufacturers to thinking like investors. Oil doesn’t matter to them - it does now, but it doesn’t psychologically. Wealth is what matters. Oil is still their golden goose - their special “10x” or “unicorn” status sauce. If the forecast for long-term global oil demand is losing steam in light of desires to shift away from fossil fuels, then perhaps sooner is the best t…

At $30/barrel they’re selling oil at a loss, not building up wealth to invest elsewhere.

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#13
post #8

I don't get it. It is estimated that below 50$/barrel Saudi Arabia is basically pushing wealth out of their country. (Balance of payment in negative, it is right?.) And below 80$/barrel they are running the country at a deficit. They are now selling to 30$/barrel. What is the strategy here? Push all "high-tech" producers out of the market and shut up the price again? How long can they last? And how much it will cost?

FWIW, I don't like the statement "KSA needs 80USD per barrel to break even". It's too blunt, and obscures lots of variables, including their bond market, their megaprojects that aren't really being paid for (yet) as they haven't started at full scale, fluctuations of external work forces, the operations in Yemen, etc etc ... were these parameters included or not? Were they compensated for in any way? I don't know the answer to those questions, although a lot of people must do. In any case, those parameters have undisputably changed since this claim was first made. And I really doubt "the Saudis" (... all 30 million of them ...) would agree to the 80USD per barrel figure.

Also, it most probably means that AT CURRENT PRODUCTION VOLUMES, ie. artificially low, they would need x USD per barrels. With more production, whatever that figure was, it will now be lower.

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#14
post #8

I don't get it. It is estimated that below 50$/barrel Saudi Arabia is basically pushing wealth out of their country. (Balance of payment in negative, it is right?.) And below 80$/barrel they are running the country at a deficit. They are now selling to 30$/barrel. What is the strategy here? Push all "high-tech" producers out of the market and shut up the price again? How long can they last? And how much it will cost?

[deleted]

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#15
post #8

I don't get it. It is estimated that below 50$/barrel Saudi Arabia is basically pushing wealth out of their country. (Balance of payment in negative, it is right?.) And below 80$/barrel they are running the country at a deficit. They are now selling to 30$/barrel. What is the strategy here? Push all "high-tech" producers out of the market and shut up the price again? How long can they last? And how much it will cost?

The liquidity crunch in the global market can be used to negotiate a better deal for Saudi Arabia. Still, it's hard to know how good it will be without knowing more details.

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#16
post #13
post #8

I don't get it. It is estimated that below 50$/barrel Saudi Arabia is basically pushing wealth out of their country. (Balance of payment in negative, it is right?.) And below 80$/barrel they are running the country at a deficit. They are now selling to 30$/barrel. What is the strategy here? Push all "high-tech" producers out of the market and shut up the price again? How long can they last? And how much it will cost?

FWIW, I don't like the statement "KSA needs 80USD per barrel to break even". It's too blunt, and obscures lots of variables, including their bond market, their megaprojects that aren't really being paid for (yet) as they haven't started at full scale, fluctuations of external work forces, the operations in Yemen, etc etc ... were these parameters included or not? Were they compensated for in any way? I don't know the…

what kind of mega projects are they involved in outside oil? I learned that they invested 40B in the SoftBank fund. Is this what you're referring to? Where would I look or what should I read to learn more about this? thanks

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#17

Saudi Arabia has shifted away from thinking like manufacturers to thinking like investors. Oil doesn’t matter to them - it does now, but it doesn’t psychologically. Wealth is what matters. Oil is still their golden goose - their special “10x” or “unicorn” status sauce. If the forecast for long-term global oil demand is losing steam in light of desires to shift away from fossil fuels, then perhaps sooner is the best t…

At $30/barrel they’re selling oil at a loss, not building up wealth to invest elsewhere.

I guess their thinking is with the current state of the world they would be selling oil at a loss anyways. So might as well slightly increase that loss and hurt their competitors as well.

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#18
post #11
post #8

I don't get it. It is estimated that below 50$/barrel Saudi Arabia is basically pushing wealth out of their country. (Balance of payment in negative, it is right?.) And below 80$/barrel they are running the country at a deficit. They are now selling to 30$/barrel. What is the strategy here? Push all "high-tech" producers out of the market and shut up the price again? How long can they last? And how much it will cost?

It's a stupid move, because the tech and reserves won't go away. As soon as prices rise again to levels needed by Saudi Arabia the reserves will be exploited again. Probably they hope that banks give less money and hedges to shale companies, but that won't work long-term. Saudi Arabia may see civil unrest soon as the house of Saud need all the money they can to spend on social welfare to stay in power.

Stupid for who?

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#19
post #8

I don't get it. It is estimated that below 50$/barrel Saudi Arabia is basically pushing wealth out of their country. (Balance of payment in negative, it is right?.) And below 80$/barrel they are running the country at a deficit. They are now selling to 30$/barrel. What is the strategy here? Push all "high-tech" producers out of the market and shut up the price again? How long can they last? And how much it will cost?

The liquidity crunch in the global market can be used to negotiate a better deal for Saudi Arabia. Still, it's hard to know how good it will be without knowing more details.

> Still, it's hard to know how good it will be without knowing more details.

Yeah, for all we know they could have loaded up on CDS on O&G plays and stand to offset any losses just by triggering default clauses on the frackers.

Re: The Saudis Have a High-Stakes Plan to Win the Global Oil War

#20
post #5

Who is that moron that wrote the article? Byzantine art of diplomacy? Saudia Arabia never existed when the Byzantines did! Also the Byzantines weren't known for their diplomacy. It's like saying the prussians enagaged in Catholic meditative sessions.

If you're not a fluent English language speaker, you might want to look at a dictionary before calling people morons. In addition to its original definition as "what the Eastern Roman Empire morphed into", it also means: "excessively convoluted" "highly complex, intricate, and devious". These other definitions unsurprisingly are based on what English language speakers thought of the Byzantines..

Right, but it is nothing specific of English language.

Oh, and the original definition should be simply "born in Byzantium", now Istambul.

Post reply on HN