Live data from Hacker News

AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

cockroachlabs.com

11–20 of 35 posts

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#11
post #6

> Azure offers a large number of configuration options that can be tricky to get right That's basically the summary of Azure. I think all that complexity ends up hurting more than it helps, not just on the end user side, but in terms of lower reliability from the provider side.

Windows is the same way: absurd numbers of options. I would not be surprised if Windows 10 had over a million configuration settings between regular panels, policies, and the registry.

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#12
post #10
post #8

Since you're one of the authors: TPC_RR is a typo.

Disclosure: I work on Google Cloud (and also commented on Cockroach’s original draft post, that this is a follow up to). Edit: I am a chump, I misread TPC _RR as TCP_RR and responded. Leaving this here for shame. Thanks to jsolson for pointing out my mistake. I’m not sure if the post was edited, but TCP_RR is definitely not a typo. You may be more used to seeing TCP_CRR which opens a new connection and then a round t…

There is still a TPC_RR occurrence in the post.

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#13
post #11
post #6

> Azure offers a large number of configuration options that can be tricky to get right That's basically the summary of Azure. I think all that complexity ends up hurting more than it helps, not just on the end user side, but in terms of lower reliability from the provider side.

Windows is the same way: absurd numbers of options. I would not be surprised if Windows 10 had over a million configuration settings between regular panels, policies, and the registry.

Absurd compared to what?

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#14

Thanks Cockroach team! I'm very excited about the possibility of moving to you guys, especially since it's a drop-in replacement for Postgres. The one thing holding us back today is postgis replacement. We rely heavily on it for location calculations and route path saving.

Working on it.

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#15
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Windows is the same way: absurd numbers of options. I would not be surprised if Windows 10 had over a million configuration settings between regular panels, policies, and the registry.

Absurd compared to what?

Compared to what humans can reasonably support.

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#16
post #11
post #6

> Azure offers a large number of configuration options that can be tricky to get right That's basically the summary of Azure. I think all that complexity ends up hurting more than it helps, not just on the end user side, but in terms of lower reliability from the provider side.

Windows is the same way: absurd numbers of options. I would not be surprised if Windows 10 had over a million configuration settings between regular panels, policies, and the registry.

You think Windows has more configuration options than Linux?

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#17
What a great marketing strategy - publishing interesting, valuable research in an adjacent area - thereby gaining genuine, valuable attention from exactly the type of person who'd also be interested in their product, whilst also establishing a kind of thought leadership in the "cloud performance" category. I'm not even being cynical - great work.

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#18
post #17

What a great marketing strategy - publishing interesting, valuable research in an adjacent area - thereby gaining genuine, valuable attention from exactly the type of person who'd also be interested in their product, whilst also establishing a kind of thought leadership in the "cloud performance" category. I'm not even being cynical - great work.

It saddens me moderately that cynicism is often the default; people sometimes think I'm being (rudely) sarcastic when I'm just being straightforwardly nice.

I feel like cynicism/pessimism gets weird praise, too. The anthropologist Wade Davis considers it an indulgence and I wholeheartedly agree.

/tangent

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#19
post #3

Previous thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21804939

This is a new post that updates the previous post with cloud vendor responses.

That's clear! Adding links to previous threads is just a service to the curious. Not intended to imply dupiness. If it were a dupe we'd have downweighted it and probably marked it as [dupe] in the title.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re: AWS, Azure, and GCP respond to cloud report

#20
For me as a developer and CTO, it's still a huge pain figuring out how to properly configure and scale AWS, Azure, or GCP. In-depth reports on "How to configure your AWS EC2 for max. performance" would be great, one report each for a specific use case, e.g. realtime chat app, basic apache webserver, nodejs web app, ... If you think about it, there are only a handful common use cases.
Post reply on HN