Live data from Hacker News

311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

anniversary7.blogspot.com

11–20 of 44 posts

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#11

It crazy that he was so confident the ship would sink he was willing to stranded, and he was right. I can hardly think of anything I am that confident in.

Well, if you're sure it's going to sink compared to resources and your survival skills, it's logical to choose the lesser of two weevils.

Is that a typo? I like it either way.

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#12
This is such an incredible story. This dude was a BA buccaneer and accomplished sailor.

He had one book with him: The Bible.

If you were allowed one book on a deserted island what book would you bring and why?

I’m taking the ESV Study Bible. Massive book with loads of commentary. Regardless of one’s beliefs it would be a phenomenal thing to concur.

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, if you're sure it's going to sink compared to resources and your survival skills, it's logical to choose the lesser of two weevils.

Is that a typo? I like it either way.

It's a joke from "Master and Commander"

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#14

Reminds me of the LOT 5055 / Il-62 / Soloviev D-30 that AgentJayZ talked about that ended up killing 183 people because the engine manufacturer was low on supply of LP main roller bearings, and so used half as many and sometimes the wrong sizes of bearings. He took apart 5 of them and they were missing these critical components, and some of the engines even wobbled by having a couple of millimeters of play when they…

Will have to dig that one up. One of my favorite channels on YouTube.

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#15

It crazy that he was so confident the ship would sink he was willing to stranded, and he was right. I can hardly think of anything I am that confident in.

His wiki article says he immediately regretted rashness in saying he rather stay on the island but the captain refused to take him back. So it seems he may have been more talking shit for effect rather than genuine and then got lucky.

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#18

This is such an incredible story. This dude was a BA buccaneer and accomplished sailor. He had one book with him: The Bible. If you were allowed one book on a deserted island what book would you bring and why? I’m taking the ESV Study Bible. Massive book with loads of commentary. Regardless of one’s beliefs it would be a phenomenal thing to concur.

I'd bring the thickest book I could get my hands on. The paper would make good tinder if I managed to keep it dry.

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#19

This is such an incredible story. This dude was a BA buccaneer and accomplished sailor. He had one book with him: The Bible. If you were allowed one book on a deserted island what book would you bring and why? I’m taking the ESV Study Bible. Massive book with loads of commentary. Regardless of one’s beliefs it would be a phenomenal thing to concur.

I'd probably bring some kind of field manual with instructions on survival. Military, boy scout, etc.

I have a decent outdoor skillset but there are many skills which I'm only aware exist, but I have never done myself (like smoking meat). I would want the advice of the manual, even if I could eventually figure it out.

Re: 311 years ago, Alexander Selkirk was rescued on a desert island

#20

This is such an incredible story. This dude was a BA buccaneer and accomplished sailor. He had one book with him: The Bible. If you were allowed one book on a deserted island what book would you bring and why? I’m taking the ESV Study Bible. Massive book with loads of commentary. Regardless of one’s beliefs it would be a phenomenal thing to concur.

I'd bring the thickest book I could get my hands on. The paper would make good tinder if I managed to keep it dry.

For what it's worth, tinder is easy to come by in most environments. Also in those days, you would likely try to never make another fire, and instead keep yours going.

Somewhat true today as well, as firelighting tools are all consumables. Some may light thousands of fires, but still would fail to eventually.

Post reply on HN