Live data from Hacker News

Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

torrentfreak.com

11–20 of 118 posts

Re: Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

#11
post #2

So two programmers ran a streaming website bigger than Netflix from their garage?

Something is fishy about this. Netflix's infrastructure is massive, and their bandwidth usage is a big chunk of the entire internet. How could this possibly go unnoticed for any amount of time?

I'd imagine the "more subscribers than Netflix" is an inflated number

Re: Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

#12
post #4

This might be a naive question but, why is the FBI the office in charge of enforcing copyright? Especially when it comes to entertainment. Why do we get an FBI warning on a cartoon's dvd?

Copyright and patent authority is explicitly granted to the Federal government by Art. I, Sec. 8 of the US constitution:

The Congress shall have Power ... To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries;

As such, state courts and police forces have no jurisdiction over copyright issues; they must be handled by the federal courts and police force (the FBI).

(Text from https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcri... )

Re: Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

#14
post #9
post #2

So two programmers ran a streaming website bigger than Netflix from their garage?

I guess Netflix needs their developers for all the random UI changes nobody is asking for and some "unrelated recommendations" engine.

Have you used any pirate streaming websites? They're pure garbage, bad UX, bad image quality, choppy video. The only reason anybody uses them is the price or lack of legal options

Re: Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

#15
post #2

So two programmers ran a streaming website bigger than Netflix from their garage?

Something is fishy about this. Netflix's infrastructure is massive, and their bandwidth usage is a big chunk of the entire internet. How could this possibly go unnoticed for any amount of time?

More content than any of the silos seems plausible, since all they have to do is aggregate.

More paying subscribers would be a huge.

Re: Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

#16
post #2

So two programmers ran a streaming website bigger than Netflix from their garage?

They were just running streaming software in front of existing torrent and NZB content. That's why they could scale relatively easy and why they were caught.

Re: Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

#18
post #5

Its like in the beginning of torrenting. Nobody willing to offer a service for everyone, for a fair price. Everybody gatekeeping selling only their stuff. And if you want everything pay this atrocious sum of money. I tell you this will happen more often and people are willing to pay. But not pay for everything. Good thing they had going. Well it was still illegal, but hey it will happen again i tell you.

Streaming is a service question. Netflix/D+/AMZN offers you a limited catalogue for 10$ or so a month. You select a movie from their website and it starts playing on your phone or computer.

Pirates offer you everything for free. You select a movie from their website and it starts playing on your phone or computer.

Why would any customer pick the more expensive product? Netflix and Friends need to offer a better service and experience at a low price. Notably that will have to include one subscription for everything.

Steam from Valve has been extremely successfull because they offer a very good service for fairly good prices. Now that EGS is trying to bleed customers, video game piracy is going up again because nobody likes exclusives except those that get money for them.

Re: Two Las Vegas Men Plead Guilty in U.S. Criminal Streaming Piracy Case

#19
post #2

So two programmers ran a streaming website bigger than Netflix from their garage?

Something is fishy about this. Netflix's infrastructure is massive, and their bandwidth usage is a big chunk of the entire internet. How could this possibly go unnoticed for any amount of time?

It's just a software in front of existing torrents.
Post reply on HN