Live data from Hacker News

Privacy: Is That iPhone?

foundation.mozilla.org

11–20 of 188 posts

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#11

Finding the settings mentioned in the article is the sole dark pattern I can think of in iOS — when you find them it’s like finding a secret level in Super Mario Land. They are under Settings...Privacy...Advertising https://imgur.com/a/EOvUzCS The Advertising and Analytics options are only visible below the fold, if one scrolls down the privacy page. The fold itself is disguised as the bottom of the page to put you o…

Did you…print out a screenshot of your phone?!

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#12

Finding the settings mentioned in the article is the sole dark pattern I can think of in iOS — when you find them it’s like finding a secret level in Super Mario Land. They are under Settings...Privacy...Advertising https://imgur.com/a/EOvUzCS The Advertising and Analytics options are only visible below the fold, if one scrolls down the privacy page. The fold itself is disguised as the bottom of the page to put you o…

I think that depends on your device size. On my iPhone SE, the bottom-most row without scrolling is HomeKit, and that is only partially shown. A single scrolling swipe easily takes me to the end of the screen where the "Advertising" section lies.

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#13
post #8

OK, so, probably an ignorant question, but here I go anyway: What, exactly, does "turning off IDFA" do? Does it send just a dummy IDFA? Or does it give you nothing at all? Why is rotating it periodically better? (I'm assuming rotation is better because that is what Mozilla is apparently recommending.)

It sends a zeroed out identifier: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/adsupport/asidenti...

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#14
post #8

OK, so, probably an ignorant question, but here I go anyway: What, exactly, does "turning off IDFA" do? Does it send just a dummy IDFA? Or does it give you nothing at all? Why is rotating it periodically better? (I'm assuming rotation is better because that is what Mozilla is apparently recommending.)

> I'm assuming rotation is better because that is what Mozilla is apparently recommending.

I'm (cynically) assuming something different. Was "monthly" chosen by accident, or is that just enough time for advertisers to connect/correlate activity from two different IDFAs?

Mozilla has big-dollar deals with the ad industry (namely, Google). Perhaps they want to appear pro-privacy while really throwing a softball?

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#16

The problem is that Apple has always claimed ios provides more privacy (& security) than android, but that's irrelevant if you don't make sure your users are capable of finding the settings. Apple has always marketed to people who are (at least perceived to be) largely tech illiterate (while claiming you have to be extremely tech savvy to use android which is a lie), so if they view their users that way they should m…

Ideally the settings would be configured in such a way that people wouldn’t have to dig through them to have it like they wanted it: it’d be set that way by default. iOS’s usually much better than Android is at this.

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#17

Finding the settings mentioned in the article is the sole dark pattern I can think of in iOS — when you find them it’s like finding a secret level in Super Mario Land. They are under Settings...Privacy...Advertising https://imgur.com/a/EOvUzCS The Advertising and Analytics options are only visible below the fold, if one scrolls down the privacy page. The fold itself is disguised as the bottom of the page to put you o…

Do you really think it's a dark pattern? What does Apple have to gain?

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#19

Finding the settings mentioned in the article is the sole dark pattern I can think of in iOS — when you find them it’s like finding a secret level in Super Mario Land. They are under Settings...Privacy...Advertising https://imgur.com/a/EOvUzCS The Advertising and Analytics options are only visible below the fold, if one scrolls down the privacy page. The fold itself is disguised as the bottom of the page to put you o…

Did you… print out a screenshot of your phone?!

I applied filters and took a screenshot of the screenshot to reduce image fidelity in case it contained any [covertly embedded]* identifying information [in the form of watermarks or hidden pixels].

*added for clarity.

Re: Privacy: Is That iPhone?

#20

Finding the settings mentioned in the article is the sole dark pattern I can think of in iOS — when you find them it’s like finding a secret level in Super Mario Land. They are under Settings...Privacy...Advertising https://imgur.com/a/EOvUzCS The Advertising and Analytics options are only visible below the fold, if one scrolls down the privacy page. The fold itself is disguised as the bottom of the page to put you o…

Did you… print out a screenshot of your phone?!

To save a photo someone sends her, my girlfriend's mother takes a screenshot. A lot of her printed photos have battery or other information on them.
Post reply on HN