Live data from Hacker News

Enable Pages access control

gitlab.com

11–20 of 39 posts

Re: Enable Pages access control

#11
post #10

Awesome. Advantage has been added. GitLab is better than GitHub, I think.

Try discovering a project/package on GitLab vs GitHub. They really need to add proper search / explore mechanism.

I'm ok with a git hosting platform that has absolutely zero social media elements to it.

Re: Enable Pages access control

#12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Try discovering a project/package on GitLab vs GitHub. They really need to add proper search / explore mechanism.

I'm ok with a git hosting platform that has absolutely zero social media elements to it.

This also affects self hosted instances in a company where you want to find other packages though. It's not a "social network" feature.

Re: Enable Pages access control

#14
post #2

Gitlab has enabled China's censorship of foreign content and free speech: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/10/16/gitlab_employees_ga...

That's not even the right outrage, their CEO said (implicitly) that they're fine being the repo hoster for software being developed for ICE...

Re: Enable Pages access control

#16
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm ok with a git hosting platform that has absolutely zero social media elements to it.

This also affects self hosted instances in a company where you want to find other packages though. It's not a "social network" feature.

You're telling me there are cases where a company has so many projects in it's gitlab instance that employees routinely have to search for things? That seems odd to me. I'd expect there to be a naming scheme for most things, and even if there's some oddball project, I'd think somebody else you work with knows about it and where it is. My company has maybe 20-30 projects, and I can find any of them easily if I know the client's name.

Re: Enable Pages access control

#17
post #16
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This also affects self hosted instances in a company where you want to find other packages though. It's not a "social network" feature.

You're telling me there are cases where a company has so many projects in it's gitlab instance that employees routinely have to search for things? That seems odd to me. I'd expect there to be a naming scheme for most things, and even if there's some oddball project, I'd think somebody else you work with knows about it and where it is. My company has maybe 20-30 projects, and I can find any of them easily if I know th…

> My company has maybe 20-30 projects

Ever worked in a company with micro services or a company that has a bunch of employees? You'll have hundreds of projects easily if it's a bunch of teams. If someone tells me "it's in our SRE libs package" I'll go ahead and search that. (Usually I can't find it because it's in a separate namespace on our Gitlab instance. Doing that is an Enterprise only feature on Gitlab right now: https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/search/advanced_global_searc...)

The point is that search is important and not a social network gimmick.

Re: Enable Pages access control

#18
post #17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're telling me there are cases where a company has so many projects in it's gitlab instance that employees routinely have to search for things? That seems odd to me. I'd expect there to be a naming scheme for most things, and even if there's some oddball project, I'd think somebody else you work with knows about it and where it is. My company has maybe 20-30 projects, and I can find any of them easily if I know th…

> My company has maybe 20-30 projects Ever worked in a company with micro services or a company that has a bunch of employees? You'll have hundreds of projects easily if it's a bunch of teams. If someone tells me "it's in our SRE libs package" I'll go ahead and search that. (Usually I can't find it because it's in a separate namespace on our Gitlab instance. Doing that is an Enterprise only feature on Gitlab right no…

I hadn't considered companies that use microservices instead of monoliths, I think you might be right

Re: Enable Pages access control

#20
post #16
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This also affects self hosted instances in a company where you want to find other packages though. It's not a "social network" feature.

You're telling me there are cases where a company has so many projects in it's gitlab instance that employees routinely have to search for things? That seems odd to me. I'd expect there to be a naming scheme for most things, and even if there's some oddball project, I'd think somebody else you work with knows about it and where it is. My company has maybe 20-30 projects, and I can find any of them easily if I know th…

I maintain several instances of large mediawiki projects which have > 50 extensions/submodules attached to it.
Post reply on HN