Live data from Hacker News

The Karma Lifecycle Of A HN Post

namesake.com

11–14 of 14 posts

Re: The Karma Lifecycle Of A HN Post

#11
post #9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's OK while it is sensible (after all, you will inform your friends you have published a new blog post or whatever) and not some heavy "please upvote" campaign.

I completely agree with that. But it seems that his "supporters" were invited at waves to give his post a boost.

This, obviously, is out of bounds.

Re: The Karma Lifecycle Of A HN Post

#12
post #7
post #4

This could be ok if he was doing an experiment about HN. These tricks of asking your buddies to upvote and retweet seems against the spirit of HN. I would be interested to see what the other HNers think.

It's OK while it is sensible (after all, you will inform your friends you have published a new blog post or whatever) and not some heavy "please upvote" campaign.

My read was that it's just a conversation about a previous post that made it to the homepage, and not an attempt to game the system.

Re: The Karma Lifecycle Of A HN Post

#13
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's OK while it is sensible (after all, you will inform your friends you have published a new blog post or whatever) and not some heavy "please upvote" campaign.

My read was that it's just a conversation about a previous post that made it to the homepage, and not an attempt to game the system.

Seems not (re-read the guidelines).

Re: The Karma Lifecycle Of A HN Post

#14
post #8
post #6

For people not aware of that site that want to see the content, just scroll up to the top in the list of what looks like comments. After 4 visits, and clicking in some places i finally got it... I must be dumb or something.

I must be dumb or something. I think they just have a poorly designed site.

It's not poorly designed, it's web2.0 designed!
Post reply on HN