Live data from Hacker News

Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

blog.nuclearsecrecy.com

11–20 of 78 posts

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#11
post #4

[flagged]

As someone who identifies with the left in India (and has always been atheist), I have to say this is unfair and really quite silly.

The Gita and other religious and literary texts like it are important cultural artifacts. They have existed since before there was such a thing as left wing vs right wing.

They may have been co-opted by particular political parties to suit particular ends, but that doesn't make them the property of those parties. Please don't associate them with politics in this way.

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#12
Bhagavad Gita is a deep scripture about yogic teachings.

The premise of the story is a war between a family fighting for dominance.

Arjuna is one of the greatest archer at the time and he was fighting against one side of his family.

Both side sought out Lord Krishna for help for their cause. Lord Krishna gave each a choice - His army or Him as a guide.

Arjuna chose Him as a guide and majority of the book is about the dialog between them.

The scripture is deeply allegorical and metaphorical. Bayasa, the author, wrote it as a guide to live one's life (Self-Realization).

The war is actually talking about the "war" every human being is fighting inside themselves. The "good" versus the "bad" or virtues versus vices. That's the whole reason why we suffer. It's all an inner journey :)

I'd highly recommend reading The Autobiography of a Yogi by Paramhansa Yogananda as his Master and other great saints explain more about it than I can.

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#14
I've been fascinated by Sanskrit because some of the words sound so much like old english/germanic. There need to be more study done on indian languages because there have just soo many of them and every region has their own dialects. It's as if the tower of babel incident happened over there.

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#15

Bhagavad Gita is a deep scripture about yogic teachings. The premise of the story is a war between a family fighting for dominance. Arjuna is one of the greatest archer at the time and he was fighting against one side of his family. Both side sought out Lord Krishna for help for their cause. Lord Krishna gave each a choice - His army or Him as a guide. Arjuna chose Him as a guide and majority of the book is about the…

What I took away from the Bhagvat Gita is that it is a treatise on why you should accept, internalize and submit to the role or place that society has assigned you.

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#16
Hinduism and ancient vedas is more of like a open source religion. So called guru's have created various meditation techniques using its knowledge and now selling it to the world. Damn i wish someone can decode it using AI and create an AI meditation guru.

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#17

Hinduism and ancient vedas is more of like a open source religion. So called guru's have created various meditation techniques using its knowledge and now selling it to the world. Damn i wish someone can decode it using AI and create an AI meditation guru.

My Commodore Amiga used to give it a shot now and again.

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#18

Bhagavad Gita is a deep scripture about yogic teachings. The premise of the story is a war between a family fighting for dominance. Arjuna is one of the greatest archer at the time and he was fighting against one side of his family. Both side sought out Lord Krishna for help for their cause. Lord Krishna gave each a choice - His army or Him as a guide. Arjuna chose Him as a guide and majority of the book is about the…

What I took away from the Bhagvat Gita is that it is a treatise on why you should accept, internalize and submit to the role or place that society has assigned you.

Yes. Lord Krishna said that to Arjuna that you might fight because it's your "duty". The death blow Arjuna deals to one of his enemy is that that enemy's "karma". Arjuna is merely an instrument/tool of God/Lord Krishna. That enemy is already "dead" whether by Arjuna's hands or another's.

That's why Lord Krishna said to Arjuna "Whatever you do, do unto Me." You're not the "doer", the "Doer" is Creation/God/shaki/energy/consciousness that's flowing within your body powering it through power of will.

I wouldn't say "society" has assigned to you but more like what Life is has placed.

"Why were you were at that exact time and place?"

"Why did you encounter every single moment at that time and/or place?"

"Why have you met the people you have throughout your life?"

Cause-Effect (Karma)

Even non-action is action which has its effect. That's why Lord Krishna chastised Arjuna for not fighting(non-action) because his ego didn't want to fight.

Re: Oppenheimer and the Gita (2014)

#19

Hinduism and ancient vedas is more of like a open source religion. So called guru's have created various meditation techniques using its knowledge and now selling it to the world. Damn i wish someone can decode it using AI and create an AI meditation guru.

My Commodore Amiga used to give it a shot now and again.

I nominate you for HN comment of the day!
Post reply on HN