Live data from Hacker News

Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

nymag.com

11–20 of 180 posts

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#11

30 years later and we have reinvented IRC, but worse as you can't use your own client, the protocol may not be public and it's harder to discover channels.

At least your friends don't need a whole lot of instruction to join. Inserting pictures is pretty easy. And it's mobile.

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#12

30 years later and we have reinvented IRC, but worse as you can't use your own client, the protocol may not be public and it's harder to discover channels.

> it's harder to discover channels.

IRC never had any channel discovery, so how does modern breed of group chats make channel discovery harder?

IRC does make a lot of things we now take for granted harder (file/image/video sharing, search, persistent history, mobile support...)

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#14
post #11

30 years later and we have reinvented IRC, but worse as you can't use your own client, the protocol may not be public and it's harder to discover channels.

At least your friends don't need a whole lot of instruction to join. Inserting pictures is pretty easy. And it's mobile.

Still with a lot of this tech, if someone sat you down for an hour and helped you, the barrier wouldn't be there.

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#15
post #2

Discord is the best thing that happened to me since IRC and I could not be happier. We exchange art, we discuss movies, we play DND together. Obviously it could not replace IRL connections, but it complements them nicely.

No idea why you're being downvoted (my hunch is that HN is extremely biased towards IRC and XMPP).

Discord is the lifeblood of a lot of gaming communities and a growing number of IT communities.

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#16
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At least your friends don't need a whole lot of instruction to join. Inserting pictures is pretty easy. And it's mobile.

Still with a lot of this tech, if someone sat you down for an hour and helped you, the barrier wouldn't be there.

Sitting down for an hour and talking about tech /is/ the barrier.

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#17

30 years later and we have reinvented IRC, but worse as you can't use your own client, the protocol may not be public and it's harder to discover channels.

> it's harder to discover channels. IRC never had any channel discovery, so how does modern breed of group chats make channel discovery harder? IRC does make a lot of things we now take for granted harder (file/image/video sharing, search, persistent history, mobile support...)

> IRC never had any channel discovery

wot? It didn't have server discovery, but once you connected to a server, you could definitely discover channels.

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#18
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Still with a lot of this tech, if someone sat you down for an hour and helped you, the barrier wouldn't be there.

Sitting down for an hour and talking about tech /is/ the barrier.

I'm reading this as you'd prefer something inherently intuitive. Which yes would be great. Some tools need at least some instruction and guidance.

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#19
post #11

30 years later and we have reinvented IRC, but worse as you can't use your own client, the protocol may not be public and it's harder to discover channels.

At least your friends don't need a whole lot of instruction to join. Inserting pictures is pretty easy. And it's mobile.

Many irc channels are as easy to join as clicking a link. Webchat has gone a long way now.

Re: Group Chats Are Making the Internet Fun Again

#20
When I hit my early 30s a few years ago all my friends moved away and had kids. Getting them together even in a virtual form to do anything in a synchronous way has become basically impossible - it leaves me longing for the days of AIM and IRC when it was very easy to make friends online.

I haven’t had a decent conversation with a stranger in years.

Post reply on HN