Live data from Hacker News

First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

searchengineland.com

11–20 of 42 posts

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#11
It sounds like he applied without ever reading about Chrome OS...

"Immediately, I realized even if I could get Twhirl to install, this was impossible with Chrome OS. There seems to be no concept of minimizing your browser, much less letting it take up less than the entire screen."

He's trying to install desktop software and minimize the browser in a browser based OS. That he can't do what he wants is central to the entire strategy of the OS.

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#12
post #11

It sounds like he applied without ever reading about Chrome OS... "Immediately, I realized even if I could get Twhirl to install, this was impossible with Chrome OS. There seems to be no concept of minimizing your browser, much less letting it take up less than the entire screen." He's trying to install desktop software and minimize the browser in a browser based OS . That he can't do what he wants is central to the…

Does bring up a good point though, I'd like to see growl like notifications in Chrome OS for twitter and email. With something like this I think users like him wouldn't mind not having a stand alone twitter application.

Another feature that might be nice would be tiling browser tabs.

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#13
post #4
post #3

The vast majority of the things he was trying to do are outside of the planned usecase of this device. It's like if someone was disappointed at the lack of photoshop on the iPad...it simply wasn't designed for that.

I was surprised that these devices have atom processors and SSD drives as opposed to an ARM chipset and embedded flash because the former specs essentially put it in netbook territory. Why would anyone want a netbook with such a limited OS?

If you look at the taken care of for you security, updates, no administration or backups to do, no apps to lose in menus, etc. etc. I think it's clear that this is supposed to be a netbook+OS frankly for people who fuck up any other OS. Your young kids, your parents, your neighbor that keeps getting malware and asking you to fix it. If google can smooth over the rough edges and provide a good enough experience for these users where things never break or get infected that may make them (or you) very happy.

If they made dealing with a camera easier I could easily see my mother adjusting to this style. And in the end it'd be easier on my father and her.

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#14
I assume these would work okay for bloggers/ writers in general. Sure I'm probably underestimating some of the tools professional writers use to organize things.

I think the main use case is really outside work, those that just want to use things like facebook/twitter and various chat platforms. Although the netbook is really the wrong form factor, you really either want a tablet or something closer to the air. With the netbook it feels like they are giving everything you can do on a regular computer but then ripping most of it out via software.

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#15
post #11

It sounds like he applied without ever reading about Chrome OS... "Immediately, I realized even if I could get Twhirl to install, this was impossible with Chrome OS. There seems to be no concept of minimizing your browser, much less letting it take up less than the entire screen." He's trying to install desktop software and minimize the browser in a browser based OS . That he can't do what he wants is central to the…

Half the article seemed to be about external monitors and hard drives... uh, hello! This is not supposed to replace your desktop people!

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#16
post #10

You can deduce two things out of this post : - First, chrome OS is still very alpha software - Second, this guy will never be the audience for such an OS. This certainly leaves the question, for who will this OS be for ? The fact of not even being able, by design, to have two windows visible at the same time is a show stopper for me. I liked the tone of the review in the end, even if it irritated me at first. The guy…

“The fact of not even being able, by design, to have two windows visible at the same time is a show stopper for me” You cannot have multiple windows on most mobile devices. Or TV's. People live fine with it.

on the other hand, it would be really neat if chrome or some 3rd party app let you split screen two windows

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#17
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was surprised that these devices have atom processors and SSD drives as opposed to an ARM chipset and embedded flash because the former specs essentially put it in netbook territory. Why would anyone want a netbook with such a limited OS?

> Why would anyone want a netbook with such a limited OS? Maybe they didn't have tablets for this pilot thing.

Nah, Chrome OS is not designed for touchscreens. There's Android for that.

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#18
post #11

It sounds like he applied without ever reading about Chrome OS... "Immediately, I realized even if I could get Twhirl to install, this was impossible with Chrome OS. There seems to be no concept of minimizing your browser, much less letting it take up less than the entire screen." He's trying to install desktop software and minimize the browser in a browser based OS . That he can't do what he wants is central to the…

I'm with the press. I was given the computer without having to apply.

I tried to install Twhirl out of curiosity, to see what would happened. I didn't expect it to work. It didn't. But it was interesting to try. Sometimes you discover things that way.

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#19
post #15
post #11

It sounds like he applied without ever reading about Chrome OS... "Immediately, I realized even if I could get Twhirl to install, this was impossible with Chrome OS. There seems to be no concept of minimizing your browser, much less letting it take up less than the entire screen." He's trying to install desktop software and minimize the browser in a browser based OS . That he can't do what he wants is central to the…

Half the article seemed to be about external monitors and hard drives... uh, hello! This is not supposed to replace your desktop people!

Actually, Google thinks it will, for many people. Just got off the phone with them about that, follow-up article tomorrow. But my review points out they already position this as a replacement computer for many people.

External monitors increase productivity. Plenty of people use them, and use them with laptops. Right now, this can't run both the internal and external monitor. Google tells me that will change.

Re: First Day Review: The Google Chrome OS Cr-48 Notebook

#20
post #10

You can deduce two things out of this post : - First, chrome OS is still very alpha software - Second, this guy will never be the audience for such an OS. This certainly leaves the question, for who will this OS be for ? The fact of not even being able, by design, to have two windows visible at the same time is a show stopper for me. I liked the tone of the review in the end, even if it irritated me at first. The guy…

“The fact of not even being able, by design, to have two windows visible at the same time is a show stopper for me” You cannot have multiple windows on most mobile devices. Or TV's. People live fine with it.

This isn't a mobile device. It's a laptop. If I can take a laptop right now with Chrome on it, break off two separate windows, why on earth wouldn't I be able to do that on a Chrome laptop? The answer is that they haven't implemented it yet. I expect they will.
Post reply on HN