Live data from Hacker News

A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

bbc.co.uk

11–20 of 24 posts

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> how reality really is Well the deaf girl can hear now, so it is clear that sometimes people do have control over natural conditions.

No, she was just was born into a time where enough suffering, has resulted in science progressing to the point and where her hearing can be fixed. The act doesn't change control over natural or personal. She was fated to get the surgery and whatever comes in life. She is no different than her reflection and similar to everything in reality. It's a shame people are so against understanding how things really are at the…

im carefully trying to understand what you are saying but it just sounds like crazy nonsense. you might reflect on whether it actually is crazy nonsense, and if not, find a more clear way to express yourself.

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, she was just was born into a time where enough suffering, has resulted in science progressing to the point and where her hearing can be fixed. The act doesn't change control over natural or personal. She was fated to get the surgery and whatever comes in life. She is no different than her reflection and similar to everything in reality. It's a shame people are so against understanding how things really are at the…

im carefully trying to understand what you are saying but it just sounds like crazy nonsense. you might reflect on whether it actually is crazy nonsense, and if not, find a more clear way to express yourself.

You sound like a person who isn't educated in determinism and so you think it's crazy nonsense. All external forces upon a person are destined to happen and where nobody has any real control over what they do or think. How's that or maybe just google hard determinism. I witness the same kind of backlash as the flat world thinkers did towards Pythagoras.

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

im carefully trying to understand what you are saying but it just sounds like crazy nonsense. you might reflect on whether it actually is crazy nonsense, and if not, find a more clear way to express yourself.

You sound like a person who isn't educated in determinism and so you think it's crazy nonsense. All external forces upon a person are destined to happen and where nobody has any real control over what they do or think. How's that or maybe just google hard determinism. I witness the same kind of backlash as the flat world thinkers did towards Pythagoras.

or do you witness the same kind of backlash that anti-vaxxers face?

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You sound like a person who isn't educated in determinism and so you think it's crazy nonsense. All external forces upon a person are destined to happen and where nobody has any real control over what they do or think. How's that or maybe just google hard determinism. I witness the same kind of backlash as the flat world thinkers did towards Pythagoras.

or do you witness the same kind of backlash that anti-vaxxers face?

Science is on the side of exhibiting determinism and science has never once provided any evidence that people have any control in this world. Free will is an illusion with how the brain functions. Most people will never spend much time thinking about it. The social conditioning in childhood ruins the possibility to think about it and prevents being even more closer to understanding reality.

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

or do you witness the same kind of backlash that anti-vaxxers face?

Science is on the side of exhibiting determinism and science has never once provided any evidence that people have any control in this world. Free will is an illusion with how the brain functions. Most people will never spend much time thinking about it. The social conditioning in childhood ruins the possibility to think about it and prevents being even more closer to understanding reality.

I guess my point really is. Even if you're right it's entirely irrelevant which makes you sound crazy.

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Science is on the side of exhibiting determinism and science has never once provided any evidence that people have any control in this world. Free will is an illusion with how the brain functions. Most people will never spend much time thinking about it. The social conditioning in childhood ruins the possibility to think about it and prevents being even more closer to understanding reality.

I guess my point really is. Even if you're right it's entirely irrelevant which makes you sound crazy.

All my points are right. I don't take life so seriously to care if I'm irrelevant on a website from time to time.

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#18
post #3

One day these implants are going to be so sophisticated that we may very well evolve to not have bio-hearing at all. I have friends with implants, and one of them regularly just keeps it switched off to focus on writing. I am deeply envious though of course, at present the bit-depth is not very good from what I understand about the tech, and his brain even after 20 years of having the implant isn't good at differenti…

2045 hackernews headline: “Senses capable of spying should have hardware switches”

2046: "Google will now let you pay for premium, ad-free hearing, in partnership with Spotify"

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#19
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

2045 hackernews headline: “Senses capable of spying should have hardware switches”

2080 hackernews headling. Google shut down hearing senses on half the population due to a software error.

Not a software error, the person responsible for the Google Ears project got the promotion they were after and now no one cares to keep it running

Re: A deaf girl who found her voice after brain surgery

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

im carefully trying to understand what you are saying but it just sounds like crazy nonsense. you might reflect on whether it actually is crazy nonsense, and if not, find a more clear way to express yourself.

You sound like a person who isn't educated in determinism and so you think it's crazy nonsense. All external forces upon a person are destined to happen and where nobody has any real control over what they do or think. How's that or maybe just google hard determinism. I witness the same kind of backlash as the flat world thinkers did towards Pythagoras.

Comparing yourself to Pythagoras after blabbering nonsense that has nothing to do with the topic. You must have HN confused with Reddit or 4chan.
Post reply on HN