Live data from Hacker News

Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

bloomberg.com

11–20 of 264 posts

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#11
Pretty interesting discussion. Working in IT and being surrounded by technology means that it's hard to stop 'working' per se. Coding on the weekend for side projects/hobbies while balancing actual 'work' means I'm clocking quite a few hours every week myself banging away on my keyboard.

No-one's putting a gun to my head to work these hours. I think awareness of the issue is great as it appears more or less systemic in China to work long hours.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#12
996 sounds like a paradise. We startup founders work 24/7. We are either working or thinking about work related stuff when not sleeping. Not that we don't know work-life balance is good for health, but you just can't stop dwelling on it if you have a devotion.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#16
post #11

Pretty interesting discussion. Working in IT and being surrounded by technology means that it's hard to stop 'working' per se. Coding on the weekend for side projects/hobbies while balancing actual 'work' means I'm clocking quite a few hours every week myself banging away on my keyboard. No-one's putting a gun to my head to work these hours. I think awareness of the issue is great as it appears more or less systemic…

Is it work though? When I learn a new language or framework through the weekend, I usually choose it out of pleasure and interest, not career concerns...

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#17
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It sounds like he's really smart. There's a billion people. He can just keep burning them out and there will be more begging to be treated that way. The only way to solve this is with regulations -- this is where capitalism breaks down. With that many people, it won't matter if he burns through them.

If you assume you have a huge reserve of capable people, then that will clamp down on wages, but as a manager you still want to optimise the productivity of the employees they have. Extreme overtime doesn't sound like a good idea. May as well hire 2 shifts of people and pay them half as much; aim for higher per-hour performance. 9-9-6 isn't going to get you very much per hour of labour time, the employees will be zom…

I think you missed my point.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#18
It’s interesting to compare the Bloomberg article with this one from the South China Morning Post, titled “Alibaba founder Jack Ma says companies forcing staff to work overtime are ‘foolish’”. Two articles reporting on the same statements and drawing completely different conclusions. It’s getting harder to find the truth.

[1]: https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3006127/alib...

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#19
post #5

Leaving aside the questions around the ethics of 996... is this kind of schedule actually effective? Do companies that work knowledge workers like this actually outperform competitors?

I spent a good chunk of my twenties working a schedule of 8 hours coding at work followed by 6 hours coding on a side project, with my entire weekend on the side project as well. I didn't have any sort of social life (largely by choice but also because I was remote working in a tiny rural village).

It was massively effective. I wrote a ton of great code. I made enough money to quit working for several years and do a startup. When you're young, moderately fit, and ambitious you can crank out a ton of code.

However, the important point is that it was my choice to do that. You can't ignore the ethics because that's what makes it wrong - asking people to do it while (even silently) implying bad things will happen if they don't is deeply unethical.

Re: Jack Ma Again Endorses Extreme Overtime as Furor Rages On

#20
post #5

Leaving aside the questions around the ethics of 996... is this kind of schedule actually effective? Do companies that work knowledge workers like this actually outperform competitors?

My guess is most people can do it for a few weeks, and some exceptional individuals could keep it up for longer.

If there are a lot of people in the company doing 996 every day I think they're probably spending most of their time doing mindless busywork.

Post reply on HN