Live data from Hacker News

Chromium-based Edge preview builds

blogs.windows.com

11–20 of 111 posts

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#11
To the surprise of no one, its basically chrome. Even my google account came in logged in automatically, same recent sites etc. I wonder if the roadmap will include things like dark mode, I never used the annotations feature so can't vouch much for it. I'm yet to try to make a MS Teams call but looking good so far.

The single engine world domination plan takes one step further today.

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#12
post #4

I think there's a tongue-in-cheek joke about IE/Edge being so bloated as is, that the only route they could take was to slap electron on top for even more memory usage. All jokes aside, are they still using Chakra or switching to V8? I know there was a ton of work in node.js to make it work with chakra, not to mention edge was one of the early adopters of many ES2015/ES6 features, it seems odd to me to abandon all of…

They're using V8. https://github.com/Microsoft/ChakraCore/issues/5865#issue-38...

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#14

It looks nice so far, but Microsoft really needs to drop the E logo, and maybe even the Edge name. Both already have negative connotations; and I don't think Microsoft can now claim that it makes it easier to find access to the internet. Especially when Chrome and Safari on tablets and phones look nothing like the iconic blue E, and yet late age boomers can still figure out the devices.

I agree with this sentiment. Edge was an extremely fast browser and I think it lost before it was even released simply by using similar branding to Explorer.

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#15

> Support for Mac and all supported versions of Windows will also come over time. Is anyone actually planning to use Edge on macOS? What reasons would you have for doing so?

Making browser cross-platform gives a bigger user base and instills confidence in developers to take a browser into consideration when designing websites, which in turn popularizes the browser as sites work properly.

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#16

> Support for Mac and all supported versions of Windows will also come over time. Is anyone actually planning to use Edge on macOS? What reasons would you have for doing so?

I would use it for browser testing websites if it's renders identically to the Windows version.

Seems unlikely to ever render identically. At the very least I believe chrome uses the platform specific font shapers (coretext on mac, cleartype on win).

So in the end, a mac version of edgeium just adds yet another browser to the test matrix columns....

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#17
post #6

Seriously, why is MS doing this? Internet Explorer died years ago, Edge never took off, and Google isn't about to give up their market share for spyware without a fight. It's like MS thinks this is Browser Wars 3.0. Heaven help me if it turns out that MS seems to be doing something comparatively good.

I think you answered your own question. Edge never took off, why continue investing money into it?

This offloads a lot of work to the open-source Chromium project, allowing Microsoft to just skin it and add whatever else they need.

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#18

It looks nice so far, but Microsoft really needs to drop the E logo, and maybe even the Edge name. Both already have negative connotations; and I don't think Microsoft can now claim that it makes it easier to find access to the internet. Especially when Chrome and Safari on tablets and phones look nothing like the iconic blue E, and yet late age boomers can still figure out the devices.

I'm not so sure that all old consumers can find another browser icon. Most in my experience look for the E.

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#19
post #13

Can we finally stop saying safari is the new ie, and recognize that chrome is now literally the new IE? Seriously, this means that chrome has more or less complete market dominance at this point.

It wasn't dominance that people were referring to, it's the intentional heel dragging to benefit other parts of their corporate family at the expense of the web that makes Safari the new IE.

Re: Chromium-based Edge preview builds

#20
post #4

I think there's a tongue-in-cheek joke about IE/Edge being so bloated as is, that the only route they could take was to slap electron on top for even more memory usage. All jokes aside, are they still using Chakra or switching to V8? I know there was a ton of work in node.js to make it work with chakra, not to mention edge was one of the early adopters of many ES2015/ES6 features, it seems odd to me to abandon all of…

They're using V8. https://github.com/Microsoft/ChakraCore/issues/5865#issue-38...

Which begs the question why would anyone use Edge when they can use Chrome?
Post reply on HN